Anthony Albanese talks a big game about sovereignty. But Australia remains in thrall to its ‘unreliable boyfriend’Julianne Schultz

We rely on US tech platforms to provide the digital infrastructure of daily life. What happens when they all go dark?

Sovereignty has become the buzzword of political rhetoric at precisely the moment it has become harder than ever to define, let alone control, and most Australians feel unsafe in the world.

It is a word that regularly trips off the prime minister’s tongue as he jets around the world to global forums.

At these gatherings leaders of proud but worried nations try to recalibrate how to deal with the old superpower. One that has become, in a phrase Canada’s trade minister, Chrystia Freeland, used as the title of her new book, an “unreliable boyfriend”. She describes a partner who became a bully. Coercive control at a global level takes many forms.

Australia has a reputation for being the most secretive democracy in the world. New laws could make it worse | Tom SulstonRead more

Once sovereignty would have been defined by territory, shaped by governments, reinforced by armies, strong institutions, electoral systems and a robust culture. Those are all still important but have been undermined.

Monopolistic global platforms now provide the infrastructure of daily life, defence, commerce, public administration, education, media, culture and everything else. Cory Doctorow graphically describes this chilling capture in his book Enshitification and, although he is hopeful that this can be reversed, it will be a tough fight.

Even with the best regulatory systems imaginable this digital infrastructure, shaped by commercial imperatives and protected and reinforced by the unreliable boyfriend’s laws and institutions, is not within national control. The prime minister likes to boast about Australia as a world leader in digital sovereignty, citing the social media ban for under-16s – an important, but very limited, first step. In practice what sounded like sovereignty feels more like accommodation.

When Microsoft went dark last week the wheels of government, commerce and ordinary life ground to a halt. At least half a billion people were directly affected – all at once and all around the world. Economies were paralysed.

At first it seemed like a bit of a joke but then the reality dawned. Microsoft Outlook, Teams, Copilot, SharePoint, Defender XDR control the fabric of modern life – email, calendars, meetings, access to files and documents.

Just the week before, David Thodey, the University of Sydney’s chancellor and a former head of CSIRO and Telstra, posed a question at a Royal Society forum considering the tipping points of existential risk. He wondered about the sovereign risk Australia faced by relying so absolutely on US technology platforms for defence and cloud services. “What would happen if Microsoft, Salesforce, Google and Anthropic all went down?” he asked.

A chill spread over the room.

The answer required a much bigger debate than we are accustomed to – about national priorities, money, ambition and delivery.

Anthony Albanese had raised a similar concern with unusual precision when he launched his approach to AI policy, saying: “If we are always dependent on someone, somewhere else, we will always be vulnerable.”

Although there has been a lot of noise since, it is unclear that the underlying sovereignty problem is being adequately addressed.

Accommodating the tech giants without giving too much away seems to be the focus.

There is an inclination to give up, as Greg Sheridan wrote in The Australian: “There is almost nothing Australia can do.”

The creative community is spearheading a campaign to address the fundamental cultural issue – the theft of copyright material to train AI models. The digital duty of care inquiry is highlighting the vulnerability of businesses which can be unilaterally removed from the platform they depend on. The research community is pointing to the catastrophic underfunding of Australian research and development.

This is not just an Australian problem. There are lessons from elsewhere, as the University of Melbourne research fellow Andrew Cullen noted: “By actively funding decentralised cloud infrastructure and homegrown software, European governments are ensuring that an American tech failure cannot knock out a local hospital. The world must adopt a similar blueprint.”

Instead, the Australian government is strengthening ties with its unreliable boyfriend. It is pouring buckets of money into a submarine and defence infrastructure project that will reshape the Australian military and economy for generations.

The links between defence and AI cannot be underestimated. As they entwine, sovereignty will become more elusive.

Aukus is already skewing industry policy towards creating military industrial research and enterprises. US anti-trans employment policies undermine Australian defence employment policy. Immunising defence sites from local laws and criminalising photographing military sites would revoke established freedoms.

Could drawing a picture of a datacentre in Australia land you in jail for seven years? | First DogRead more

The independent inquiry into Aukus concluded that the $368bn agreement is a deception that threatens to surrender Australian sovereignty.

The government did not but in the inquiry but a thousand others did, including eminent experts, former prime ministers, ministers, generals, admirals and ambassadors. They can’t all be wrong. The failure to engage and take part in a robust debate highlights a sovereign vulnerability.

The Australian National University’s National Security College released a survey this year that showed that Australians were worried about security and wanted more money spent at home to provide greater resilience.

The inquiry’s Surrendering Australia report showed that the billions allocated to Aukus could instead fund 44 conventional submarines, 180 major hospitals, 1.47m homes, upgrade every public school, eight years of the national disability insurance scheme, and solar power and batteries for every home.

We should at least have an open debate about whether that would strengthen resilience and sovereignty more than dependence on an unreliable boyfriend.

  • Julianne Schultz is the author of The Idea of Australia


Explore more on these topics
  • Australian foreign policy
  • Opinion
  • Datacentres - Australia
  • AI (artificial intelligence)
  • Australian politics
  • Anthony Albanese
  • Australian military
  • Aukus
  • comment
ShareReuse this content