Australia’s music industry says it will oppose a reported proposal to exempt musicians from a broader plan allowing AI companies to train on Australian content, arguing the approach would leave other creative sectors exposed. Australian Recording Industry Association (Aria) CEO Annabelle Herd called the reported scheme “unnecessary, unworkable and designed to suit the commercial interests of AI companies, not protect creators”.

The Australian Financial Review reported on Thursday that the government was considering requiring AI companies to buy permits to train on Australian content, with music potentially exempted. Guardian Australia said it could not independently verify the proposal. A senior creative-sector figure involved in copyright discussions said they had heard some details, while other sources said they had not and doubted the Albanese government would seriously consider it. An unnamed AI industry source said they would welcome the plan.

Herd said she had not heard of the proposal before Thursday and that the music industry would not abandon other creatives. “Our position is unchanged: we stand with the rest of the creative and media industries,” she told Guardian Australia.

Claire Pullen, CEO of the Australian Writers’ Guild, also rejected the idea. “I can’t see any creative workers leaving their colleagues behind,” she said. Pullen said creative groups had been working with the government on a model since 2024, but that technology companies had refused to discuss proposed solutions.

Herd and Pullen questioned how an exemption could work for films and television shows combining copyrighted music, video and screenwriting. They also said such a scheme would be technically difficult to implement.

The Media, Entertainment & Arts Alliance said it would be “alarmed” by the reported proposal and said protections promised by Prime Minister Anthony Albanese “must apply to all creative sectors”. Albanese has said it would be “theft” if creatives were not paid for their work and that artists “need to be compensated”.

The proposal also drew criticism from politicians. Shadow attorney general Michaelia Cash said it would “divide the rightsholders”, while independent senator David Pocock called it “some sort of divide and conquer strategy”. Greens senator Sarah Hanson-Young urged the government not to meet copyright demands from big tech, warning that Australia could become “known as the Cayman Islands for AI” if it allowed the loophole.

The government did not comment on the reported proposal. Industry Minister Tim Ayres said on Tuesday that “the status quo is no good” for creative workers. Acting Prime Minister Richard Marles repeated that line on Thursday and said on News24: “People are being ripped off”. Attorney General Michelle Rowland’s spokesperson said Australian creatives’ work was being used without their consent or payment, adding that the government had long urged technology companies to make commercial deals with Australian artists.