An NSW coronial inquest has heard that routine checks and follow-up might have saved four babies who died after free or home births in the state’s Northern Rivers region between 2022 and 2024.
The inquest in Lismore is examining the deaths of Baby DH, Baby D, Baby R and Baby B. Evidence has described women choosing free or home births for reasons including traumatic experiences, distrust of clinicians and a lack of services.
Baby DH died about eight hours after a free birth attended by a doula, with no medical professionals present. The court previously heard he turned purple, struggled to breathe and became floppy. His parents said they were worried, but the doula reassured them their baby was OK and then left. The doula denied many of their claims and denied giving them clinical advice.
Expert neonatologist associate professor Nicholas Evans told the court on Friday that Baby DH’s complex heart abnormalities “would have been readily detectable” in a routine pregnancy scan, which would have led to a referral to a paediatric cardiologist. He called it a “missed opportunity”.
Paediatric cardiologist Dr Paul Brooks said it was “highly likely” all the abnormalities would have been identified in a routine scan. Even if their full extent was unclear, he said, the scan would have shown that the baby needed to be born at a major hospital with cardiac surgery capabilities. “The site of [Baby DH’s] birth meant that he didn’t have a chance.”
Baby D’s mother did not know she was carrying twins. She initially thought she had delivered Baby D’s placenta, then realised it was a stillborn second twin. Experts said it was impossible to know exactly why Baby D died. They discussed whether self-described birth keeper Sita Tara Kali’s failure to clamp the umbilical cord before cutting it could have contributed. Evans said respiratory distress related to compromised heart function was the most likely cause.
Evans said Baby D might have survived if someone able to perform advanced resuscitation had arrived in under 10 minutes. But he said the “root cause” was that the mother’s twin pregnancy had not been identified before the births. “If [twins] had been diagnosed, at 18 weeks, as it would usually in pregnancy, there would have been very close monitoring.”
Baby R likely died of “severe post-maturity” after being born at 43 weeks and one day in a free birth. The standard is to induce birth or perform a caesarean section at 42 weeks, as an ageing placenta puts the baby at risk.
The mother had an ultrasound at 12 weeks that gave a due date of 28 July, 2020. The court previously heard she distrusted hospitals and trusted Kali, her birth keeper. Kali advised her to calculate the due date from conception, an unreliable measure that put it in mid August. Evans wrote in his report that the recalculation was the “root cause” of the issue.
“The standard practice now is that you don’t allow a pregnancy to go beyond 42 completed weeks,” Evans told the court on Friday. Expert midwives earlier told the inquest they did not have statistics for babies born beyond 43 weeks because it was so rare.
An ultrasound on 19 August showed the pregnancy had become a medical emergency. Kali advised the mother to “go home and rest”. Evans said it was “more likely than not” the baby would have survived if the mother had gone to hospital after the ultrasound.
Baby B’s mother was repeatedly warned to give birth to her twins in hospital but was determined to have a home birth. Four midwives assisted her rather than let her have a free birth, and the head midwife repeatedly counselled her about the risks.
The mother declined ultrasounds and a test for early onset group B streptococcus (GBS), an organism present in 15 to 20% of women that infects the babies of about 2% of carriers. Evans told the court on Friday that Baby B likely died of GBS, pneumonia and sepsis. His twin became ill but survived. Evans said many infected babies survive in hospital thanks to antibiotics.
The inquest is ongoing.
