Democrats’ 3 November victories offer a lesson for the party’s future, argue Dustin Guastella and Jared Abbott: blue-collar populist candidates outperformed both professional-class progressives and corporate-backed centrists in their analysis of the results.
The party ran about 15 points ahead of Kamala Harris’s 2024 margins on average, and won seats in districts Donald Trump had carried by double digits two years earlier. But the authors caution that the scale of the backlash against Trump does not mean any Democrat will win in 2028. They say the party still needs a program and political pitch for the next election.
Democrats nevertheless continue to struggle with working-class voters, the authors write. Fifty-seven per cent of 2026 voters lacked a four-year degree. In 2024, voters without a college degree shifted seven points toward Trump, moving from a six-point Republican margin in 2020 to a 13-point margin. In 2026, they swung back by 17 points.
Democrats won college graduates by 26 points and voters without degrees by four points, leaving a 22-point education gap. They lost white voters without degrees by 19 points, according to the article. The authors argue that winning a durable majority will require stronger support from these voters.
The authors say the 2026 results do not show that the most liberal candidates were best placed to win back working-class voters. Justice Democrats-backed nominees ran about one point below the authors’ estimate of a typical Democrat’s performance in the same district, while Bernie Sanders’s Senate endorsees ran about six and a half points below it. The measure, called “wins above replacement”, or War, accounts for the district’s 2024 presidential vote, demographics and whether an incumbent was running.
But the authors argue that centrist claims about the results also overlook the performance of blue-collar populists. Brian Poindexter, a union ironworker in Ohio; Bob Brooks, a firefighter in Pennsylvania; Sam Forstag, a former smokejumper in Montana; Rebecca Cooke, a waitress in Wisconsin; and Randy Villegas, a community college professor from California’s Central valley, outperformed professional-class progressives and centrists in the authors’ analysis.
Poindexter ran almost 11 points ahead of the typical-Democrat estimate, Forstag about five points ahead, Cooke about four and Brooks about two. Their average was about +5, compared with about +2 for nominees backed only by the Blue Dogs and roughly even results for those backed only by Sanders. Villegas, whose race was still being counted, ran about 14 points ahead.
The article says the four Blue Collar Brigade nominees — Poindexter, Villegas, Forstag and Brooks — averaged a War of nearly +8. All four outperformed comparable Democrats by about eight points on average. No other progressive or centrist group averaged better than about +3.
The authors describe the strongest model as a “Bernie-dog” candidate: someone who leans left on wages, jobs and the economy, discusses those issues in plain language, and takes a more centrist position on immigration and criminal justice. They say such candidates can speak to frustration with trade deals that sent jobs overseas while combining patriotism and tradition with support for working people.
They also point to social class as a political issue. Troy Jackson, who the article describes as the soon-to-be senator from Maine, faced an attack ad questioning his competence because of his background. Susan Collins’s “cord of wood” ad implied Jackson was better suited to logging than legislating. Jackson went on to unseat Collins.
Guastella is a research associate at the Center for Working Class Politics and director of operations for Teamsters Local 623. Abbott is director of the Center for Working-Class Politics. They conclude that Democrats seeking to win back working-class voters should invest more in blue-collar populist candidates.
