The conviction and jailing of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault, and allegations of sexual misconduct and grooming against David Walliams, which he has denied, have revived debate about whether the UK should introduce a “staggered” age of consent. Campaigners and survivors say sex with 16- and 17-year-olds should be illegal for adults more than four years older than them.

The allegations against Brand and Walliams, which emerged after newspaper and television investigations, including by the Guardian, included claims that both men had sexual relationships in their 30s with girls aged 16.

“I think we all agree that adults shouldn’t be allowed to have sexual relationships with children, with somebody under the age of 18,” said Mia Latter, who alleged she was raped by Brand when she was 16 and he was 30.

Layla Stone, a child protection social worker who leads the Close the Consent Gap campaign group, said 16- and 18-year-olds were considered children in “every single framework of the law”. “We don’t believe [they are] old enough to consent to having sex with much older adults,” she said.

The age of consent in Britain is 16, a threshold set in 1885 after public outcry over the case of Eliza Armstrong, a 13-year-old sold for sex by her mother. The law followed a four-part exposé by newspaper editor WT Stead, who arranged for Armstrong to be taken to a brothel to demonstrate that young girls were being sold for sexual exploitation.

More than 140 years later, the debate raises a broader question: when does childhood end and adulthood begin? The answer varies across laws and cultures, and rights are often granted at different ages.

Sixteen- and 17-year-olds can join the armed forces in the UK. In Scotland and Northern Ireland, they can marry with parental permission. In almost all US states they can drive, while in Malta and Austria they can vote in local and national elections. In the Netherlands, they can get a tattoo without parental consent. But in the US, people under 21 cannot buy beer.

Laura Lammasniemi, an assistant professor of law at the University of Warwick, said the age of consent reflects more than physical maturity. “Often we think of age of consent as being related to physical maturity, but there’s clearly a very strong religious and political aspect to it as well,” she said.

In England and Wales, the 1885 consent law applied only to unmarried girls. Girls could marry at 12 until 1929, and within marriage their sexual acquiescence was taken for granted. Lammasniemi said the disparity reflected moral judgments: “If the sexual behaviour was somehow considered to be potentially harmful, you needed a higher age to consent to it than you did for something like marriage, which was considered to be generally a social good.”

The legal age for sex between gay men was not equalised until 2000, after partial decriminalisation for those over 21 in 1967. Lesbian sex did not appear in English law until 2003. Northern Ireland raised its age of consent from 16 to 17 in 1950; it was brought into line with the rest of the UK in 2008.

Internationally, ages and rules vary. Subject to additional provisions, including those for close-in-age relationships or authority figures, sex is permissible at 14 in Italy, Germany, Brazil and much of Central America, and at 15 in France and Sweden. The age is 17 in Ireland, Cyprus, South Australia and Texas. Fourteen US states, including California and Florida, set it at 18. Argentina permits sex in some circumstances from 13.

Rachel Thomson, a professor of childhood and youth studies at the University of Sussex, said sex is often “the first form of adulthood that you get to try out”. But neither the legal age nor the age at which teenagers first have sex offers a clear measure of the transition to adulthood. She said the gap between first intercourse and milestones such as a first live-in relationship or first child has widened since the late 20th century.

Thomson said the transition to independence had changed, with many young people moving between home and independence rather than following a straightforward path. “There has been a real transformation of the scaffolding outside of the family that makes it possible to become autonomous and independent in the world,” she said. Earlier patterns of leaving school at 16, finding work and setting up home in one’s 20s were “largely obsolete”, she said.

The extended transition to adulthood is consistent with research showing that the brain continues to develop into the late 20s. Some experts have argued adolescence should be redefined as spanning ages 10 to 24. Sarah-Jayne Blakemore, a professor of psychology and cognitive neuroscience at the University of Cambridge, wrote that there is no single age at which the brain can be classified as adult, because development is continuous and varies between individuals.

Legal thresholds also differ for other rights and responsibilities. The minimum age of criminal responsibility ranges from seven in some African and South Asian countries to 18 in Brazil and Peru. England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and most Australian states, set it at 10; the threshold for federal crimes in the US is 11.

Eighteen is a major legal milestone in much of the world, but Christine Huebner, a lecturer in quantitative social sciences at the University of Sheffield, said the idea of a fixed boundary is misleading. “This idea that we have this magic boundary at 18, that has never really existed,” she said. Young people acquire rights at different ages, she added, and some decisions may carry greater consequences than others.

Huebner followed young people aged 15 to 21 in a research project, asking how adult they felt and why. Participants cited milestones including donating blood, which is permitted in the UK at 17, starting a first job, driving and graduating from university. “There are multiple little signifiers of what it means to contribute to society and they come up at different times and different circumstances,” she said.

Carey Oppenheim, an expert in social policy relating to childhood and inequality, said the routes to adulthood had become “more complex, longer and more precarious – and they remain very unequal”. She said support for young people, including specialist mental health services, can stop at an arbitrary age even as traditional milestones such as getting a job or leaving home are delayed.

“The cliff edge at the age of 18, or wherever that cliff edge is, is not a very good way to organise support for young people as they navigate their transitions into adulthood,” Oppenheim said. Her report for the Nuffield Foundation recommended recognising early adulthood as a distinct and extended phase of life.