Campaigners and legal experts have backed Joanne Young’s call for scrutiny of consent laws after four men were convicted of sexual offences against her, while stressing that action must also address wider issues around sexual assault and public understanding of consent.
Young, who was drugged and raped by her husband and sexually abused by men he invited into their home, said there were “serious questions about how the law deals with consent”. Her daughter, Alex Young, called for the law to make clear that third-party consent cannot be used as an argument in court.
Philip Young, 50, advertised Joanne Young, his then wife, on dating and swinging websites, presenting it as a “kink” for both of them, Winchester crown court heard. Jurors were told he had been sedating her, leaving her in an “inanimate state” in which men who answered the adverts could do anything to her. The former Conservative councillor pleaded guilty earlier in the year to dozens of charges of abuse against his former wife, who has waived her right to anonymity.
The four men, strangers to each other, were convicted on Thursday. The trial heard that they did not seek Joanne Young’s consent before engaging in sexual activity with her. They said they had been duped by Philip Young and believed she was consenting. Young, 49, said: “No one should be able to give [consent] on your behalf.”
Barristers and campaigners said no law states that third-party consent is a valid defence, and called for public debate and further education about consent.
Kate Parker, a criminal barrister and founder of the charity Schools Consent Project, said: “The law currently has nothing in it which allows someone to point to another person and say: ‘Because of what they told me, I believed the other person to be consenting.’ You can’t effectively outsource consent to a third party, the law has never had that within it. The Sexual Offences Act 2003 certainly doesn’t have that in it.
“What is instead happening is defence counsel in this case, and in cases like this, are pointing to a defence you can run, which is to say that the defendant genuinely and reasonably thought that the victim was consenting.”
Parker said defendants should be able to explain what they believed at the time of an alleged offence, but hoped greater public knowledge of consent law would reduce the traction of such arguments with juries.
“I think that’s a sort of cornerstone of our law. But I hope that these arguments carry less and less traction with juries when generally there is more knowledge as to what the laws around consent are,” she said.
“I hope that as time goes by, juries become more aware and members of the public become more aware as to what the law on consent is, so no one can say: ‘Because a third party told me so and I acted on it, I thought I was legally safe.’”
Harriet Wistrich, a solicitor and director of the Centre for Women’s Justice, said the jury in the Young case had rejected the defence. “It should be obvious in the law that somebody can’t consent on somebody else’s behalf. But you could explicitly make it the case,” she said.
“Defence barristers should robustly defend their clients. That’s their job. But they shouldn’t overstep the mark by relying on myths and stereotypes.”
Ciara Bergman, chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, said consent law should be scrutinised. The Sexual Offences Act 2003 states: “A person consents if he agrees by choice, and has the freedom and capacity to make that choice.”
Bergman said the existing law was clear but was regularly misinterpreted and misapplied by defendants, barristers and juries. She said consent is specific and ongoing, depends on the situation, and that an unconscious person cannot consent. She added: “The other thing about these cases is that drugging someone is the opposite of consent. What is emerging from these organised drug-facilitated sexual abuse cases is a growing recognition of the attraction that some people have to a woman not being able to consent.”
Prof Miranda Horvath, director of the Institute for Social Justice and Crime at the University of Suffolk, said incorrect beliefs about consent should be “robustly challenged”. She said: “It is incredibly important that people understand that legally nobody can give consent on your behalf, and this underlines the importance of clear education on consent through society, from young people right through to adults.”
“Rape and serious sexual offences are a direct choice made by perpetrators, and a lack of understanding on whether a sexual partner has given consent cannot be an acceptable excuse,” Horvath said.
Labour MP Jess Phillips said the government should consider whether the law needed to be tightened. “It is absolutely right that the government should strength-test whether there is a way of really asserting in the law that consent cannot ever come from a third party – we need to be absolutely satisfied that that is the case,” she said.
Phillips added: “There is an argument that while the law states that consent cannot come from a third party, we still see it being used as a defence. Perhaps if we look at tightening the law, these men would have had to plead guilty and Joanne Young would have been spared this trial.”
A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: “The law is clear: no one can consent on someone else’s behalf. Consent must come from the person themselves, and they must have the freedom and capacity to make that choice. We keep the criminal law under review, and we will always look at what more can be done to protect victims.”
