The African Union officially launched the Africa Credit Rating Agency (AfCRA) on October 7, fulfilling an initiative first endorsed by African leaders in 2017. Based in Port Louis, Mauritius, the agency aims to assess African governments and corporate borrowers using local data and expertise, complementing ratings from international agencies. Its first sovereign ratings are expected by the end of March.

AfCRA interim chief executive Sifiso Falala said the agency is in discussions with 15 African governments. Research is planned in countries including Mauritius, Kenya, Togo, the Seychelles and Burundi.

The agency’s launch comes amid long-running concerns among African governments that international rating methods do not adequately reflect the continent’s economic structures and circumstances. A 2023 United Nations Development Programme study estimated that subjectivities in sovereign credit ratings cost African countries $74.5bn through excessive interest payments and foregone lending.

Moody’s, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings have disputed claims that their assessments systematically disadvantage African borrowers. At a Chatham House discussion in June, Moody’s Marie Diron said the agency’s analysis of four decades of global sovereign default data showed African countries with a particular rating had broadly the same default probability as equally rated borrowers elsewhere. She said a sovereign with a B rating had an estimated one-year default probability of about 5 percent, whether it was African or from another region.

Falala said AfCRA is not seeking more favourable ratings, but greater accuracy through engagement with established agencies. “Our objective is not to manufacture better ratings for Africa, but to produce more accurate ratings of Africa in collaboration with established rating agencies. Importantly, we believe that a stronger AfCRA will contribute to a stronger credit rating industry overall,” he said.

The agency plans to assess companies, municipalities, banks and local-currency debt as well as sovereign borrowers. The wider coverage could provide domestic investors with more information about borrowers that receive limited attention from international agencies. However, additional ratings will not automatically reduce borrowing costs; their influence will depend on whether investors find them credible and useful.

Abdussalam Muazu, an associate chartered economist at the Institute of Chartered Economists of Nigeria, said limited information about African borrowers contributes to uncertainty in lending decisions. He told Al Jazeera that local knowledge could help fill data gaps, including information about informal trade, mobile money and community finance.

Dayo Obisan, a financial market professional, told Al Jazeera that African countries need rating methods that better reflect their economic circumstances and access to capital. He said an Africa-focused agency could offer richer local data, contextual insight, wider coverage and support for domestic markets.

AfCRA will need to demonstrate that its methods are rigorous, consistent and transparent, and that its ratings can withstand scrutiny from investors beyond the continent. Its ownership and financing arrangements will also be closely watched. The agency describes itself as privately owned and self-funded, and its planned sovereign assessments will be solicited, meaning governments pay for ratings and provide access to officials and financial information.

The African Union says governments may not own shares in AfCRA. The agency will nevertheless need to show that commercial relationships with the borrowers it assesses do not influence its analysis. Its credibility will depend on whether investors trust its assessments, its methodology withstands scrutiny and it remains independent when findings are politically inconvenient.

As Falala put it, “What strengthens AfCRA should ultimately strengthen the credibility of the entire credit rating industry. Africa needs more credible assessments, not competing narratives.”