As negotiations to form Israel’s next government approach their first deadline on December 6, caretaker Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appears to be seeking to exploit divisions in the opposition “change” alliance trying to oust him.

Netanyahu met former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, a leading figure in the alliance, on Wednesday in an undeclared meeting. The encounter prompted accusations that Netanyahu was trying to fracture the bloc from within.

Netanyahu’s office described the two-and-a-half-hour meeting as a “security briefing”. Sources in the opposition alliance led by Gadi Eisenkot called it a “strategic disaster”, according to Israeli media. Bennett had not told Eisenkot about the meeting in advance, sources told Ynet. Channel 12 reported that, at a subsequent gathering of opposition leaders, Bennett argued they should consider a unity government with Netanyahu.

Bennett and other prominent members of the opposition have previously served in Netanyahu-led governments. Eisenkot joined Netanyahu’s emergency unity government after the Hamas-led October 7, 2023 attack on Israel, serving as a minister without portfolio and a member of the war cabinet. Avigdor Lieberman, another right-wing member of the opposition bloc, served as Netanyahu’s foreign minister and defence minister.

“Netanyahu is trying to break up the [opposition] bloc for change through Bennett,” a senior figure in the Eisenkot-led alliance told Ynet. The article noted opposition leaders’ pledges, including Bennett’s, never to serve in a Netanyahu-led coalition again.

The alliance spans a range of political positions, from Lieberman’s hard-right policies to the relatively left-wing platform of Democrats’ leader Yair Golan. Several of its members have previously worked with Netanyahu, leaving the bloc’s ability to remain united uncertain.

Bennett was once among Netanyahu’s closest political allies and served in several of his governments. He broke with Netanyahu in 2021, when he joined centrist Yair Lapid to form an alternative administration. Their cross-party coalition ended Netanyahu’s 12 consecutive years in office, with Bennett serving as prime minister for the first half of its term. Bennett still shares many policy positions with Netanyahu.

The bloc’s members supported Israel’s war on Gaza, described in the article as genocidal, at least at its start, as well as its attacks on several regional states, including Iran and Lebanon. On domestic policy, however, they differ markedly.

Eisenkot and Bennett’s electoral partner, Yair Lapid, are regarded as relatively centrist. Bennett and Lieberman are on the right, with differing views on religion: Bennett is a religious nationalist, while Lieberman is a staunchly secular politician with a background in Israel’s Russian-speaking community. Golan is on the left, supports a two-state solution with the Palestinians and has criticised settler pogroms in the occupied West Bank, accusing the government of encouraging or tolerating them.

Eisenkot faces the task of finding 13 additional seats for a parliamentary majority. His bloc holds 48 of the parliament’s 120 seats after the October 27 elections, according to the article, leaving him reliant on bridging political differences among his allies to form a government.

Golan has met political leaders from parties representing Palestinian citizens of Israel and spoken enthusiastically about forming a government with their support. The rest of the bloc has rejected that suggestion. It has also drawn fierce opposition, with right-wing protesters threatening civil war over the prospect.

Lieberman, whose Yisrael Beytenu party holds seven seats, has strongly opposed any government dependent on Palestinian support. His opposition to the de facto exemption of ultra-Orthodox Jewish men from military service, however, appears to be softening in light of the alternative of seeking the 13 seats held by the ultra-Orthodox parties Shas and United Torah Judaism.

A compromise by Lieberman on conscription could undermine one of his central electoral promises, as well as those of other opposition leaders, and prompt a backlash from supporters.

Disagreements have surfaced publicly. In August, Bennett called Eisenkot’s proposal for limited military-service exemptions for ultra-Orthodox men an “insane mistake”, warning that Aryeh Deri and Moshe Gafni would “run circles around” him. Eisenkot later accused Bennett and Lieberman of engaging in “old politics” and hurting the opposition’s electoral prospects by refusing to agree that the alliance’s largest party should lead the next government.

Weeks before the election, Lieberman called Eisenkot “Gantz 2.0”, referring to former defence minister Benny Gantz, who joined Netanyahu’s government in 2020 despite campaigning against him. Lieberman accused Eisenkot of secretly pursuing a deal with Netanyahu and acting out of personal ambition. Days after the election, Golan told Lieberman that if he continued to insist on a government that avoided conscripting ultra-Orthodox men, he was “welcome to form one with Netanyahu”.

Some opposition leaders’ past assessments of Netanyahu were less critical. In 2020, Bennett told reporters that, despite personal differences, he respected Netanyahu “very much”. He said Israel had “won a victory” by having Netanyahu in office for so long and that he had “done great things” for the country.

In 2019, Lieberman told The Jerusalem Post that he wished Netanyahu “only really good results” and hoped he would be acquitted on the corruption charges that Lieberman has since cited repeatedly as evidence that the prime minister is unfit for office.