On Thursday, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) held a state responsible for committing genocide for the first time in its 80-year history. By nine votes to six, the court found that Myanmar’s 2017 campaign against the Rohingya crossed the gravest threshold in international law.
The court found that Myanmar’s government forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, committed widespread sexual violence, inflicted extreme violence on children and attacked people fleeing towards Bangladesh. Considering the evidence together, it concluded that the “only reasonable inference” was an intention to destroy a substantial part of the Rohingya population in northern Rakhine state.
Myanmar argued that its “clearance operations” followed attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) and were counterterrorism operations, however brutal. But genocide requires specific intent to destroy a protected group, not only proof of killing, rape or village destruction. The court’s ruling found that the ARSA attacks and armed conflict did not excuse genocide or reduce the atrocities to excesses by rogue soldiers.
The ruling was split 9-6, but it is final and binding. By 10 votes to five, the court also ordered reparations, including safe, voluntary and dignified return, family reunification, restitution of property and compensation where restitution is impossible.
For Rohingya survivors, the ruling is a major vindication. Yasmin Ullah, a Rohingya rights activist who sat in the courtroom, called it “a great day for the Rohingya”. Refugees in Cox’s Bazar have said they want to go home with rights, citizenship and dignity.
The ICJ has no enforcement arm. Under Article 94(2) of the United Nations Charter, noncompliance can be referred to the UN Security Council (UNSC), where China or Russia could block action. The article says pressure beyond the UNSC is therefore essential, including targeted sanctions, ASEAN diplomacy, the ICC investigation and Argentina’s universal-jurisdiction case, where arrest warrants have already been issued for 25 suspects.
Control of Rakhine has also changed since 2017, when Myanmar’s military dominated the state. The Arakan Army now controls most of it. UN investigators have documented forced recruitment, movement restrictions, arbitrary killings and other abuses against Rohingya under its rule.
The article argues that any return framework must address whoever controls the ground. It says Bangladesh should link cross-border trade, humanitarian access and political engagement with the Arakan Army to measurable benchmarks, including freedom of movement, land restoration, an end to forced recruitment, international monitoring and a pathway to citizenship. It also calls for Bangladesh to press Myanmar’s authorities, ASEAN, China, India, Gulf states and Western governments to support a monitored return-and-reparations mechanism.
The article also warns that funding shortages threaten refugees while return remains uncertain. About 95 percent of Rohingya refugees are moderately to highly vulnerable and rely almost entirely on humanitarian assistance. The UN’s scaled-down 2026 response plan seeks $710.5m, 26 percent less than the previous year’s appeal.
In April, the World Food Programme reduced support for about two-thirds of refugees under a new tiered system; about 17 percent now receive only $7 per person per month. The article urges donors who welcome the verdict to fund support for refugees, and says the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, Gulf donors, Western governments, lenders and donors have roles to play.
The ruling gives reparations legal force, the article says. Property claims should be documented, land restored where possible and compensation paid where it cannot. It concludes that the test is whether Rohingya can return as citizens, reclaim their land, receive compensation and raise their children outside refugee camps.
The views expressed in the article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.
