Al Jazeera independently confirmed that the Tim Hortons app shares user data with Forter, an Israeli cybertech company, prompting renewed concerns in Canada over consumer privacy and the scope of information collected.
On Tuesday, Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East (CPJME) said the app sends “sensitive user data” to Forter. The group also raised concerns about the company’s founders’ links to an Israeli military intelligence unit accused of mass surveillance of Palestinians and reportedly associated with Lavender, an artificial intelligence (AI) system used to generate lists of Palestinians to be targeted during Israel’s genocidal war on Gaza.
The findings follow an investigation by Canadian broadcaster CBC, reported last week, into data-sharing practices of popular apps. CBC did not identify the company receiving Tim Hortons users’ data or say where it was based.
Tim Hortons told CBC that sharing data with Forter is a fraud-prevention measure. The chain said Forter is not allowed to sell data collected through its app and that Tim Hortons does not sell users’ personal information. Neither Tim Hortons nor its parent company, Restaurant Brands International (RBI), had responded to Al Jazeera’s queries by publication. Forter had also not responded.
Joel Reardon, a computer science professor at the University of Calgary whose research underpinned the CBC investigation, told Al Jazeera: “The collection occurs prior to consent, and in my view is excessive.”
CBC found that the Tim Hortons app appeared to send data to a third party as soon as it launched. The information includes unique identifiers, sensor details and the names of nearby Wi-Fi networks, which Reardon said can be used to determine a person’s location. He said Forter gathers enough information to create a digital fingerprint for each device and recognise it later.
“I’m usually troubled by the precise ongoing location data collection because that can reveal a great deal of information about an individual,” Reardon said. He added that fraud prevention can be carried out without collecting data that gives users’ precise locations.
CPJME warned that the practice could expose consumers to privacy risks beyond the stated purpose of fraud prevention. “What concerns us is that there is this massive … digital footprint being built of people through these apps, seemingly without their knowledge, in the name of preventing fraud, and that data is flowing to an Israeli cybertech company whose operations … [are] opaque to us and [who] have concerning ties,” Jason Toney, CPJME’s director of media advocacy, told Al Jazeera.
OpenMedia executive director Matt Hatfield said: “People open the Tim Hortons app to order a coffee, not have their data, including location indicators, exported to foreign companies.” He added that Tim Hortons is not unusual: “Many companies quietly pass data to a long chain of vendors that customers have never heard of and never chose.”
“We effectively create these chains of trust that our data is handled appropriately – where any company along the chain can breach and abuse our data,” Hatfield said.
Toney noted that Forter’s founders have previously said the data it receives is used to protect “wealthy corporations” from fraud. “If a consumer’s credit card is fraudulently used, for example, to purchase something online, it’s usually the wealthy corporations that are on the hook for reimbursing that funding,” he said. “So they use Forter to avoid having to take on those costs … It’s not really about protecting ordinary consumers, at least that’s not how they have framed it publicly in the past.”
Questions also remain about whether users understand what they agree to when using the app. Johanna Gunawan, an assistant professor of computer science and law at Maastricht University, told Al Jazeera that “consumers are frequently unaware of the particulars they consent to when accepting a privacy policy”. She said such policies are lengthy and often not written in plain language.
“The cognitive load to understand the full privacy implications of acceptance is frequently imbalanced against the relative ease or speed of providing agreement,” Gunawan said.
Forter’s founders – Michael Reitblat, Liron Damri and Alon Shemesh – are all alumni of the Israeli military’s Unit 8200, its signals intelligence and cyberwarfare division, The Times of Israel has reported. The Jerusalem Post reported in 2018 that the company’s technology is enhanced by Israeli military intelligence.
Last year, Microsoft barred the Israeli military from some of its services following an investigation that found Unit 8200 used its Azure cloud computing platform to store phone call data obtained through mass surveillance of Palestinians in Gaza and the occupied West Bank. The division has also been associated with Lavender, the AI technology that Israel has created to target Palestinians during its genocidal war on Gaza.
Toney said the links were “concerning” but cautioned against speculating that Forter uses data from the Tim Hortons app in a “nefarious” manner. He said there is no evidence of this and that the Israeli firm appears to be well established. Forter says on its website that it provides fraud-prevention services to companies including eBay, Shein, Reebok and LG Electronics.
Al Jazeera was unable to confirm whether Forter still uses Israeli military intelligence or whether data it holds is accessible to the Israeli government or military agencies.
In 2022, Canadian federal and provincial privacy commissioners found that Tim Hortons’ app had illegally tracked users’ locations through a third-party provider, even when the app was closed. Hatfield said the company faced no fines because Canada’s privacy regulator cannot issue them.
Hatfield said Canada’s privacy laws are insufficient and outdated. “Our federal private-sector privacy law, PIPEDA, is more than 25 years old. Under it, a company can send your data to a service provider without asking you, as long as it says it remains ‘accountable’ for that data,” he said, referring to the Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act.
“In practice, Canadians often can’t find out who receives their data, which country it ends up in, or which foreign laws or governments might be able to reach it,” Hatfield said. He argued that companies should tell customers directly and respect their preferences about how their data is used.
Hatfield said Bill C-36, the government’s proposed privacy legislation introduced in June this year, “would only partially help”. He said it would require a privacy impact assessment before data leaves Canada and introduce financial penalties, but would still allow companies to share data with service providers without consent. Those providers would be directly bound only by the bill’s security and breach-reporting rules.
Hatfield also said the bill would require a new regulator to consider factors beyond privacy, including Canada’s trade agreements, economic growth and the broader public interest, before launching an investigation into a privacy violation. “In practice, this may mean that while privacy violations may be more clearly illegal once C-36 passes, the Canadian government could pressure the regulator to ignore violations associated with close trade partners,” he said.
CPJME is calling for another inquiry by the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada into Tim Hortons’ handling of consumer data, Toney said. Al Jazeera contacted the commissioner’s office but did not receive a response.
CPJME has also filed a complaint with the CBC’s ombudsperson, alleging violations of journalistic standards and practices because CBC did not identify Forter in its investigation. “CBC’s reporting obscures the true scale of the privacy risk Tim Hortons has exposed its users to. CBC is letting Tim Hortons and Forter off the hook. Canadians deserve to understand the truth,” Toney said.
Gunawan said companies should take responsibility for the privacy and security practices of third-party technology providers. “That’s simple transparency and due diligence,” she said.
Hatfield said questions about a vendor’s links to foreign military or intelligence services “are legitimate and deserve clear answers. The same standard should apply whether the vendor is American, Chinese, Israeli or Canadian.” He said Tim Hortons should publicly identify every third party receiving data from its app, explain why the data is shared, and disclose where it is stored and who can access it.
“And frankly, it shouldn’t be giving our data to anyone when its business is selling coffee and doughnuts!”
