Opposition to datacentre projects has grown from a marginal concern to a mainstream issue in some Australian communities, with grassroots campaigners sharing information and tactics as they challenge proposals.
In March, a motion raised by Heather Champion opposing a gas plant proposed to power a large datacentre in New South Wales’ Southern Highlands failed to pass Wingecarribee council. Five months later, a motion calling on the federal government to introduce a moratorium on new datacentres passed unanimously.
“I think the council’s change in perspective is a direct result of the change in sentiment in the community,” Champion says.
Campaigners point to several recent project setbacks. Since Guardian Australia reported in May on proposals in Hazelmere, Western Australia; West Footscray, Victoria; and Lane Cove, New South Wales, proposals in WA and NSW have been withdrawn. NextDC’s M3 expansion in West Footscray has stalled after power provider Jemena delayed installing taller power poles following community opposition.
Sasha Titchkosky, a spokesperson for Lane Cove Responsible Planning, says she is working with groups in western Sydney and the Southern Highlands following the withdrawal of the Goodman Group’s Mars datacentre proposal in Lane Cove. She says the groups’ cooperation signals to industry and politicians that they need to do better.
Councils have a role in approving datacentres in some states. In NSW and Victoria, however, fast-tracked approvals can bypass local councils. The federal government has proposed rules that would take effect next year and set minimum requirements for large datacentres, covering energy, water, costs, community engagement, location and workforce impacts.
Titchkosky argues that regulations alone are insufficient if approvals continue before the rules take effect. “Just saying they’re going to put in place regulations, but still allowing datacentres to be approved … isn’t good enough.
“They [need to] either put a pause on approvals or basically say that everyone who gets approved now will be subject to the regulations when they come in force.”
Campaigners across Australia share information and advice through WhatsApp, where they organise rallies and discuss proposals. A community wiki in Victoria maps proposed datacentre locations and the groups campaigning around them, and links to campaign advice from US groups that lobbied against the sector in the recent midterm elections.
Titchkosky has also been in contact with campaigners in the Southern Highlands. An application refusal for one of three proposed gas plants, capable of producing 673MW of power in total, is being challenged in the NSW land and environment court. Applicant Cloud Carrier wants to use the plant to power a “data campus” in Moss Vale with AI “at its core”.
“We’ve been in touch with Lane Cove for quite a long time,” Champion says. “We are sharing skills, messages – it’s very lateral and it’s very informal.” She says campaigners share what has and has not worked, while recognising that approaches suitable for one area may not suit another. “ [Lane Cove’s] circumstances are just so completely different but in some ways that’s been really helpful … having [our] voices combined does provide some breadth.”
The groups are also working with western Sydney communities to help them respond to new centres planned for the area. Mandy Ottaviano, a University of Sydney masters of sustainability student researching community action against datacentres in Australia, says there is a “real desire” for groups to connect, but no formal organisation.
“What we’re not seeing a lot of yet is [non-government organisations] stepping in and bridging that gap in terms of coordinating those groups in a meaningful way together,” Ottaviano says. “We haven’t yet seen any emergence of a national kind of coalition.”
Data Centres Australia chief executive Belinda Dennett acknowledges “more interest from the community” in datacentre development than ever before. She says companies are increasing community consultation through information sessions, door-knocking, newsletters, websites, hotline phone numbers and social media updates. Dennett also called for greater coordination and information sharing among companies delivering energy, broadband and water infrastructure.
Campaigners say proposed government rules do not go far enough. A New South Wales parliamentary inquiry into datacentres released its report earlier this month, after the committee removed recommendations calling for the state to advocate for a moratorium until new obligations are in place and for the proposed federal rules to apply retrospectively.
Greens MP Abigail Boyd, the inquiry chair, was the only committee member to support those recommendations. “It appears that both the Labor and Liberal parties remain in hock to the industry talking points,” she wrote in the report’s foreword.
Boyd said she was disappointed that Labor and Liberal members opposed a pause on approvals until binding obligations were in place, and opposed advocating for projects already in the planning pipeline to meet rules under consideration. She said the delay to federal rules “makes clear the coordinated effort by governments and industry to avoid having to comply with even the most moderate of environmental and social obligations”.
Champion says she was “really frustrated” that the recommendations were removed. “We agreed between the group of us we would call for a moratorium, and all the community groups know that’s what’s needed. It feels like a real cop-out to be honest.”
Titchkosky says the major parties’ position on datacentres is “clear as day” and questions whether it could prove politically damaging, citing the role of datacentre concerns in voter sentiment in the US midterms. “They’re ultimately prepared to sell out communities for multinational corporate interests,” she says. “I think we are going to see the same issues play out in Victoria and NSW in our upcoming elections as they were in the US midterms. ‘Communities are really angry about this.’”
