The US Army plans to destroy 68 drums of deteriorating lead azide at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant, but a federal court has temporarily blocked the operation while it considers a challenge to the emergency permit authorising it.

The controlled detonations were initially scheduled for Friday, November 20, and later postponed to Monday, November 23, after public pressure. The Army has not announced a time for the blasts. On Thursday, the US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit issued an interim stay of the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) permit, temporarily preventing the Army from proceeding as the court weighs a request for a longer-term injunction. The stay is not a final ruling, and the Justice Department said Friday that the federal government could invoke separate emergency powers to bypass the permit requirement.

The Iowa Environmental Council and the Sierra Club’s Iowa chapter filed the legal challenge on the eve of the original operation. They argued that the EPA had failed to provide meaningful advance notice, require adequate safeguards for health and the environment, or sufficiently consider safer disposal options.

The Army’s November 15 advisory warned residents of Middletown, a southeastern Iowa city of about 360 people, that the blasts could produce loud explosions, ground vibrations and a dust plume containing “some lead”. The Army plans to drench the soil above the earth-covered concrete magazines where the chemicals are stored, and says sand-filled barriers around the structures are designed to direct the force upwards.

The Army’s modelling predicts elevated airborne lead levels but says they would remain “below the level at which EPA would require protective actions be taken”. Patrick O’Shaughnessy, an environmental health professor at the University of Iowa who will monitor the fallout, told Al Jazeera that the Army has not disclosed how much lead each blast could release. “The unprecedented aspect of it is that normally in the world of air pollution, we have some estimation of what’s called the emission factor, the emission strength. We know how many pounds per second will be distributed out into the air from a smokestack,” he said, “but in this case, we have no idea.” He warned that lead could settle on playground equipment, crops, back yards and other surfaces where people may be exposed.

The Army discovered the deteriorating stockpile during a safety review in March. The lead azide had been stored for 20 years at the 19,000-acre plant in Des Moines County, about 16 kilometres (10 miles) west of the Mississippi River. The 68 barrels contain roughly 9,700 pounds (just under five tonnes) of explosives, including roughly 6,900 pounds (about 3.5 tonnes) of lead by chemical mass.

Liquid in the drums evaporated during storage, causing the lead azide to recrystallise and become more sensitive to shock and friction, according to the Army’s environmental assessment. “Due to its chemical degradation, the material’s legal status transitioned from a viable production component to an unserviceable hazardous waste,” the report states.

Army Sustainment Command spokesperson Justine Barati said the Army faced a narrowing window to destroy the material before colder weather or disturbances increased the risk of spontaneous detonation, which could kill technicians on-site. “We’re trying to do a controlled detonation to minimise the impact to the community and the environment. This is not something that we take lightly. We know that this is a disruption to people and that is not our intent, but we’re trying to do this in the safest manner possible,” Barati told a local television news station earlier this week.

Lead azide is an inorganic compound of lead and nitrogen, with lead making up about 71 percent of its mass. The Army’s fact sheet says the heat from a proper detonation “incinerates” the lead azide. But Bruce Lanphear, a paediatric epidemiologist and professor of health sciences at Simon Fraser University, said the blast does not destroy the lead. “When lead azide detonates, it decomposes primarily into nitrogen gas and lead,” he told Al Jazeera, “the lead may be released as fine particles of metallic lead, lead oxides, and other lead compounds. The explosion doesn’t destroy the lead. It redistributes it.”

Dr Aaron Specht, an associate professor at Purdue University’s School of Health Sciences, said: “Everyone should be shocked to learn this problem has been left long enough to warrant the potential catastrophic fallout from this situation.”

Lead exposure can be harmful even below regulatory limits. The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) says no blood lead level in a child is considered safe. Lanphear said exposure can damage children’s cognitive and neurological development, and that high doses can cause encephalopathy or premature death. He also co-authored a 2018 study estimating that long-term lead exposure was linked to 412,000 deaths annually across the US, including 256,000 from cardiovascular disease.

Fetuses exposed through the mother’s bloodstream, pregnant women and young children are among those at particular risk, according to the article. Children are especially vulnerable because their developing nervous systems are sensitive to lead and comparatively small amounts can reach biologically significant doses.

The EPA issued the emergency permit five days before the original detonation date. The Army had previously held an open house in mid-October at the Army Reserve Center for residents within a 50-mile (80km) radius, where it outlined its plans to address the explosive hazard.