A coalition of five international aid organisations has given US President Donald Trump’s Gaza peace plan four out of 26 points, saying it has failed to ensure humanitarian access and protect civilians. The assessment comes one year after the United Nations Security Council endorsed the plan and amid continued Israeli military operations and new evacuation orders in Gaza.
The Danish Refugee Council, Norwegian Refugee Council, Oxfam, Refugees International and Save the Children issued the scorecard. It awarded the plan no points for humanitarian access and one point for civilian protection. The organisations said the plan’s provisions were being violated as Israeli forces launched a new ground offensive in central Gaza and advanced west of the “Yellow Line”.
The aid groups also cited the expanding area under Israeli military control. According to OCHA, the “Yellow Line” has moved west, increasing the area controlled by Israel from 58 percent of Gaza at the start of the ceasefire 13 months ago to 65 percent today. A UN official told the Security Council in June that Israel said it controlled 70 percent of the territory.
OCHA said last month that Palestinians are barred from crossing the line, leaving roughly 2.1 million people confined to 128sq km (49 sq miles), or 16,000 people per square km. A recent NPR map analysis put the area at 109sq km (42 sq miles), with a population density of nearly 19,300 people per square km.
At least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed and 5,975 wounded since the “ceasefire” was declared in October last year, the agencies said. “When you’re in Gaza, it does not feel like a ceasefire,” Shaun Hughes, World Food Programme country director for Palestine, told journalists. He said Israeli military control across nearly 70 percent of Gaza leaves people with almost no space to grow food, while fishing is prohibited and life-threatening and unemployment is over 80 percent.
Lilu Thapa, executive director for the Middle East, Asia and Europe at the Danish Refugee Council, said: “Palestinians in Gaza are being confined as the “Yellow Line” expands. This is displacement by design, and a ceasefire that allows it is a ceasefire in name only.”
The organisations and Palestinian rights advocates also criticised the Board of Peace and the International Stabilization Force, established by Trump to oversee the diplomatic framework. Ramy Abdu, founder and chairman of the Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor, said the Board lacked meaningful Palestinian representation and had undermined Palestinians’ right to self-determination.
“Instead, it has effectively become a political shield for Israel’s occupation and its crimes, contributing to the perpetuation of genocidal conditions while providing political cover for grave violations of international law,” Abdu told Al Jazeera. “The available evidence supports describing the Board’s role as a form of functional normalisation of genocide and starvation.” Mohsen Abu Ramadan, a board member of the Palestinian NGOs Network, said the Board had “failed the international community” and continued to provide political cover for “ongoing genocide and atrocities.”
The plan stipulated that at least 600 UN-coordinated humanitarian aid trucks would enter Gaza each day. An average of 49 such trucks entered daily in September, according to the article. It said just two percent of the convoys carried medical supplies, while Israeli authorities increasingly prioritised commercial trucks with goods that many residents could not afford.
During the week of October 12, 315 commercial trucks entered Gaza: 223 carried food, 51 non-essential items, 12 hygiene and shelter materials, and one medical supplies. Israel has cited “dual use” restrictions on goods that could have military as well as civilian purposes.
Jan Egeland, CEO of the Norwegian Refugee Council, said: “The suffering of Gaza’s 2.1 million people is not inevitable. The world must stop accepting it.” Oxfam America President Abby Maxman said conditions were a “direct result of policy choices made in Israel, the US and at the UN.”
As Gaza enters its fourth winter of displacement, nearly 1.4 million Palestinians are living in makeshift shelters, and reconstruction has yet to begin, despite donors pledging about $18bn for Gaza through the Board of Peace. A recent winter storm flooded more than 70,000 tents in one day, killing an infant and five displaced people, the article said. More than 150,000 tents and 500,000 blankets are waiting outside Gaza for permission to enter, while supplies inside the territory are virtually exhausted.
Save the Children International CEO Inger Ashing said: “One year ago, the world was promised that Gaza’s children would finally see safety, relief and a chance to rebuild their lives. Instead, they are colder, hungrier, more traumatised and more at risk than they were before.” Refugees International President Jeremy Konyndyk said: “The United States and other UN Security Council members must use their leverage to ensure those obligations are met.”
Gaza’s health ministry has reported that 2,027 patients have died while awaiting medical evacuation and 21,000 remain on waiting lists. Abdu called for the enforcement of International Criminal Court arrest warrants for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other officials, continued International Court of Justice genocide proceedings against Israel, universal jurisdiction cases in national courts, regional arms embargoes on Israel and a public Security Council briefing on the Board of Peace.
Al Jazeera asked the Board of Peace to respond to the allegations. Its head of communications, Brad Klapper, sent the outlet the Board’s latest official report via WhatsApp but did not address specific claims about territorial encroachment or aid-truck access. When asked for direct answers, Klapper said: “This is your reply. You have our assessment of where things stand.”
The report acknowledged that implementation of the plan had been limited and attributed delays in several areas to decisions pending from Israel’s government. It said the absence of decisions on arrangements for training, deploying and returning civilian police to Gaza impeded implementation. It also urged Israel to make decisions needed for the police, the National Committee for the Administration of Gaza and the International Stabilization Force to enter Gaza.
The report said Hamas and Palestinian factions accepted a 15-point roadmap on July 30 to relinquish their weapons and transfer full authority to a transitional administration, but that mechanisms to implement the roadmap remained paralysed. It concluded: “A ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely. The people of Gaza have paid the highest price for this war and should not be asked to pay again for delay.”
