A Florida jury found mechanic Dwain Hall guilty of murdering British music teacher Sonia Exelby, 32, who prosecutors said suffered from mental illness. Hall had pleaded not guilty to kidnapping and first-degree murder.

Hall, an auto repair and tow truck driver, met Exelby, from Portsmouth, England, on a fetish website and persuaded her to travel to the United States. Authorities said he picked her up at Gainesville airport after she arrived in Florida in October 2025.

Prosecutors said Exelby had posted online about wanting someone to end her life. Hall’s arrest affidavit said she had previously expressed suicidal thoughts, and investigators alleged he knew of her struggles and used her vulnerability to bring her to Florida, the Ocala Starbanner reported.

At trial, jurors heard from witnesses, mostly law enforcement officials, about Hall’s emails, phone records, social media accounts and other records used to trace his movements after Exelby travelled from the UK to meet him. Investigators said they later found evidence at an Airbnb rental linking Hall to her disappearance and death, including transactions on her bank cards and a video of Exelby on his cellphone.

Authorities said Exelby boarded a flight to the US seemingly with an intention “to be possibly sexually abused, tortured and murdered by unknown individuals living in the United States”.

Hall’s attorney, Junior Barrett, argued that Exelby took her own life. “She came here with the intention of dying, she thought she was worthless, useless, a burden on other people,” he said in his closing statement.

“This isn’t a question about what porn he likes. You can disagree with him about what he likes, but the case can’t be decided on you not liking his lifestyle. The fact he did not stop her from killing herself does not make it murder.”

Prosecutor Amy Beth Berndt urged jurors to use their “common sense”. She said Hall targeted Exelby because of her mental illness and killed her for his sadistic pleasure. Berndt said Exelby “was beautiful. She was kind and she was deeply loved by everyone who knew her. And she also suffered from mental illness for most of her life. She should be alive today.”

Berndt added: “No one could save her from the defendant, the ‘Alpha Sadist’. He took advantage of a severely depressed, mentally ill woman who was incapable of making any rational decisions.”

After the verdict, Exelby’s brother Barry Wilton said: “This last year has been one of the hardest of our lives. Losing our dear sister Sonia has had a profound impact on me and my entire family. I’m not sure we will ever be the same again.”

Wilton then addressed Hall directly: “You pretended to care for Sonia. You didn’t at all. You used her to fulfil your sick fantasies. You had her life in your hands. You had the opportunity to save her, but instead you preyed on her vulnerabilities and you took her from us.”