AI is increasing the mental strain on workers already facing unpredictable incomes, insecure housing and debt, with the lowest-paid most affected, argues Professor Dame Henrietta Moore. She says governments should rethink welfare as AI reshapes the economy.
Moore says economists have increasingly recognised “brain capital” — the judgment, creativity and insight people bring to work — as machines take on routine tasks. The World Economic Forum says analytical thinking is now the skill employers value most and estimates that 59 in every 100 workers will need training to adapt by 2030.
At the first Global Brain Economy Summit in New York in September, Moore asked how much room people have for creativity and learning when they are worried about paying rent or affording food. She says two indices ranking countries and US states on brain capital use about 60 indicators, including child poverty and the prevalence of Parkinson’s disease, but do not measure whether people have secure livelihoods. The World Health Organization includes safety and security among the foundations of brain health, she notes, but says index builders did not ask people what drains their mental capacity.
Moore calls this unmeasured burden “cognitive taxation”: a levy on attention, memory and learning imposed through rents, debt and welfare paperwork. She says chronic worry over insecurity can wear down the brain, and argues that AI is increasing the burden.
She describes how a worker whose rent rises and whose shift is cancelled at short notice might use a credit card to cover the gap, then return a benefits form late and lose part of a payment. Such setbacks, Moore says, can leave a household poorer in money, headspace and health.
A 2024 analysis of 112,000 people in the Journal of Economic Psychology found that financial scarcity measurably impairs thinking, with the effect easing when pressure lifts. Moore also cites research finding that low-paid workers in rural India who received wages a few days early were 7% more productive and made fewer mistakes. In South Africa, after the pension age for men was lowered from 65 to 60, those who became eligible earlier showed slower memory decline and were about five percentage points less likely to develop dementia.
Moore argues that AI can add to cognitive strain before it eliminates jobs by making schedules less predictable, shifting or shortening work hours. She points to Walmart staff dealing with AI-set schedules and research by the Boston Consulting Group indicating that overseeing AI tools adds mental fatigue. Workers may also struggle to retrain if worries about pay, housing and debt already occupy their attention.
In Britain, about 2.7 million people are out of work through long-term sickness. Moore says research by her institute found that people facing insecurity across several areas of life have an earnings penalty as large as the gender pay gap, roughly doubling after seven years. She says the findings suggest worry erodes work performance. The UK’s AI minister has said the technology could have “an unprecedented impact” on the jobs market.
Moore contrasts universal basic income with universal basic services. Elon Musk told reporters at the White House in September that AI would bring “universal high income”. But a study funded by Sam Altman, which gave low-income Americans $1,000 a month, found mental health gains faded after the first year, Moore says. Cash can help, she argues, but does not ensure access to childcare or reliable transport.
She advocates universal basic services, including childcare, housing, transport and digital access, free at the point of use. Moore says the approach follows the principle behind the UK’s National Health Service: people should be able to rely on essential support without a bill when they use it. Extending free childcare alone is expected to bring 60,000 non-working parents into jobs in the UK.
Moore says governments should assess how fiscal policies affect the cognitive load of the poorest people they touch. She argues Britain should raise the issue with the world’s largest economies when it takes over the G20 presidency after December’s summit in Miami, and says it should be considered in fiscal plans, brain-capital indices and AI-powered public services.
Moore concludes that, just as economies learned to count damage to air and water, governments should measure the harm done to people’s minds as AI makes human judgment increasingly valuable.
Professor Dame Henrietta Moore is founder and director of the UCL Institute for Global Prosperity and co-leads The New Alignment, the institute’s G20 policy programme.
