Originally published by The Guardian. By Eleanor Gordon-Smith.

I’m engaged but I can’t stop thinking about an old friend. Should I tell him how I feel?

Telling him would risk a lot of harm, advice columnist Eleanor Gordon-Smith writes. If you’re going to take that gamble, you’d better be sure why you’re doing it

  • Read more Leading questions

My partner and I are engaged after a whirlwind romance, and I was over the moon when he proposed. He is a wonderful, kind and generous man, and will be an amazing husband. However, I’ve since found out that a friend I’ve known for years has always carried a torch for me, and this knowledge has made me see him in a different light. I can’t stop thinking about him, and it’s making me question if I should marry my fiance. My friend has no idea I feel this way, and has recently got engaged, so nothing has obviously changed, apart from my feelings.

Do I continue with planning my wedding and push these new feelings down, or do I tell my friend how I feel in case he still feels the same? This indecision is torturing me.

Eleanor says: Strong feelings tell important truths. Figuring out what important truths they tell is a whole other story.

Why do you think this discovery made you see your friend so differently? Were you unhappy with your fiance before this; were you attracted to your friend before?

If not, there’s a chance that the strength of this feeling isn’t a guide to its accuracy.

My best friend is pregnant. I’m happy for her but not good with babies. How can I be supportive? | Leading questionsRead more

Big life transitions, like getting married, mean foreclosing possibility. For every commitment we make about how life will look, we shut down all the ways it might have looked instead. We decide those other lives will stay permanently unrealised, cold, still. This isn’t a good feeling, even if the thing you’ve chosen is clearly the right choice. Nobody likes to feel the doors of possibility closing. It’s too close to the feeling of running out of time. Before you put on the ring, or take the job, or buy the house – whatever the big decision is – imagination can dance between your options, inhabit them all, give a pretty good simulacrum of what it would be like to have them all. But once you make the commitment, that goes away. If you’re lucky enough to have had multiple good options, that means even rational choices can contain a soupcon of grief. Moving down one life path means declining and mourning multiple others.

Against that, reminders of possibility can look to us like a flare on a dark sea.

Sometimes that’s what draws us romantically to a new person, especially at critical life junctures. We mentally go back to them over and over, and not necessarily because of who they are. When we return to the state of weighing our options, we can go back to feeling free. We can go back to that imaginative space where our life still bursts with potential.

Telling him would risk a lot of harm to your fiance, your friend, and your friend’s fiance. If you’re going to take that gamble, you’d better be sure this sudden attraction is really to him, and not what he represents. It’s exciting to know that he carried a torch for you, of course. But his feelings weren’t enough to prompt him into confessing them, nor to mean he couldn’t imagine marrying someone else. And we don’t yet know whether that torch could light the warm hearth of marriage: a lot of people will love the idea of you.

Suppose there is a real chance that things would be better with this friend. Is that enough? Are uncertain chances of improvement enough to reject the certainly good? Not usually.

Most of us don’t trade in a good we’re confident in for the uncertain chance of an uncertain gain. So if it really does feel like this might be a tempting trade, that could be a sign you aren’t ultimately confident about your existing relationship.

Strong feelings can tell important truths. But there’s a difference between what feelings appear to be saying and the truths they actually tell. On the surface this feeling is saying something about your friend. But the deep truth it’s revealing might be something else altogether.

Ask Eleanor a question

Explore more on these topics
  • Relationships
  • Leading questions
  • Australian lifestyle
  • Marriage
  • features
ShareReuse this content