A dispute over when to publish the next major climate science assessment is threatening to delay its use in global climate negotiations, observers said at COP31 in Antalya.

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) began assessing the latest climate science in 1988. Its reports, published every six to seven years, underpin major international climate agreements, including the 2015 Paris Agreement. The latest report was published in 2023.

Work on the seventh assessment report should already have started, but an IPCC plenary session was put on hold in October at the urging of Russia, Iran, Saudi Arabia and Kenya. The dispute centers on whether the next report should inform the 2028 global stocktake, which will assess climate efforts and shape plans to cut greenhouse gas emissions.

The European Union, Brazil, the United Kingdom, small island states and other countries especially vulnerable to climate change have called for the report to be published in 2028. Russia, Iran, India and Saudi Arabia want it postponed until 2029, after the stocktake.

The official reason given for delaying the report is that the tight schedule could harm research quality and limit participation by researchers and governments from developing countries. Budget disagreements have also slowed the IPCC’s work. Funding helps cover travel for hundreds of volunteer scientists, particularly those from poorer countries, to attend IPCC sessions.

“No budget means no more IPCC,” said a member of another delegation, speaking off the record. A European delegation diplomat, also not speaking on the record, said: “We are extremely concerned about the situation,” adding that the dispute concerned the future of the IPCC.

A spokesperson for Germany’s Environment Ministry told DW at COP: “The IPCC finds itself in a difficult situation. We stand ready to help resolve this issue, so that the panel can continue its work. To that end, we are holding many discussions with various countries to explore possible solutions.”

Researchers have said the proposed schedule is achievable. An open letter released in October and signed by more than 100 researchers from 36 countries, including India and China, said: “We have no time to lose. We stand committed to continue working to deliver the [seventh assessment report] in a manner that is rigorous, timely and inclusive.”

The dispute over timing will not change the scientific findings themselves, but could delay their political impact. In pre-COP communications, France accused countries seeking to delay publication of attempting to “obstruct science in order to lower the ambition of the global stocktake.”

At COP31 on November 17, EU Climate Commissioner Wopke Hoekstra said it was “fundamental to protect the integrity of climate science and the role of the IPCC as the source of best available science.” There is no vote on the IPCC at COP31, but the panel’s role and a timetable for its next report could appear in the final declaration, expected this weekend.

The article also reported concerns about a presentation on COP31’s electrification targets. DW obtained a copy of the presentation, which contained misleading statements, and two countries confirmed its contents. The presentation’s origin could not be verified.

Turkey has proposed raising global electrification to 35% by 2035 to reduce reliance on fossil fuels. The presentation portrayed electrification as a business venture benefiting wealthy countries at the expense of poorer nations. The International Energy Agency has calculated that developing countries could save around $100 billion (€90 billion) in fossil fuel imports by 2035 through electrification.

The presentation also suggested that all countries must meet fixed electrification targets. According to the UN, the 35% figure is a global goal, and individual countries can determine their own national pathways.