Afghanistan’s Taliban authorities accuse Pakistan of supporting armed groups opposed to their rule, but Islamabad denies the allegation. Analysts interviewed by DW differ on whether Pakistan is providing such backing and what its aims might be.

Taliban Foreign Minister Amir Khan Muttaqi recently alleged that Pakistan had launched a "project to destabilize Afghanistan." He claimed that "thousands of armed individuals have gathered along the Durand Line (Afghanistan-Pakistan border) to undermine the stability achieved in Afghanistan."

The allegations follow months of clashes along the border between Afghan Taliban and Pakistani forces. In July, the Afghanistan Freedom Front (AFF), an anti-Taliban group, reportedly clashed with Taliban forces in Zebak district in northeastern Badakhshan province. The group said it also carried out attacks in Nooristan and Kunar provinces in October. The United Front of Afghanistan, another "resistance group," claimed it attacked Taliban forces in Kandahar province, near the Pakistani border.

In an interview with DW's Pashto-Dari service in September, Taliban spokesperson Zabihullah Mujahid alleged: "The people who created insecurity in Badakhshan crossed from Chitral [in Pakistan] and later fled back to Chitral. They had been brought in. Even Pakistani military personnel were with them," Pakistan's Ministry of Information dismissed the allegations as propaganda.

Groups opposed to Taliban rule say they receive no external support and that their resistance is purely indigenous. More than five years after returning to power in Kabul, the Taliban have consolidated control over Afghanistan and largely suppressed armed resistance groups and political dissidents.

Shinkai Karokhail, a former Afghan member of parliament, told DW it would be logistically difficult for anti-Taliban Afghan groups to cross the Pakistani border and enter Afghanistan without Islamabad's support. She was referring to clashes in Badakhshan and Nooristan provinces.

Some US officials have claimed that Islamabad continued supporting the Taliban after the September 11, 2001, terrorist attacks in the United States. Islamabad has always rejected those allegations. Afrasiab Khattak, a Pakistani political analyst and former senator, told DW that Pakistani support for anti-Taliban groups is "real." He said: "Taliban opponents come to Islamabad, hold meetings, and it is a part of Pakistan's policy toward Afghanistan."

Qandil Abbas, an associate professor of politics and international relations at Quaid-i-Azam University in Islamabad, disagreed. "Pakistan may provide political support [to Taliban opponents], but not military support," she told DW.

Ali Ahmad Jalali, a professor at the Near East South Asia Center for Strategic Studies at the National Defense University in Washington DC, said Islamabad may be backing Taliban opponents as a "leverage." "When such incidents take place along the Afghanistan-Pakistan border, and given Pakistan's history of support for Afghan groups, it would not be surprising if Pakistan is supporting these groups," he said.

Pakistani officials have repeatedly urged the Taliban to act against anti-Pakistan militant groups, particularly the Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), which is responsible for attacks on Pakistani civilians and soldiers, and the Baloch Liberation Army (BLA), an outlawed armed separatist group active in Balochistan province. Islamabad alleges the groups organize and launch attacks in Pakistan from Afghan territory with Taliban support.

At the Economic Cooperation Organization (ECO) summit in Islamabad this week, Pakistani Foreign Minister Ishaq Dar said: "Meaningful progress requires Afghan authorities to address legitimate security concerns of neighboring countries, particularly the threat of terrorism." On Friday, Islamabad said Afghanistan had not been invited to the ECO gathering because Pakistan does not recognize the Taliban regime in Kabul.

Jalali, who served as Afghanistan's interior minister from 2003 to 2005, said Islamabad is demanding something the Taliban may neither be willing nor able to provide. "Pakistan wants the Taliban to cooperate in fighting against groups such as the TTP. But the TTP has long fought alongside the Afghan Taliban. There are ideological as well as friendly ties between the two. They seek a similar political system, and some Afghan Taliban members may even be among TTP fighters," he said.

Analysts also cite the Taliban's efforts to strengthen relations with India, Pakistan's long-standing regional rival, as a concern for Islamabad. Malek Sitez, an Afghan expert and researcher of international relations, said Pakistan does not want Kabul to grow close to New Delhi, among other reasons, but no longer has the influence over Afghanistan it once had.

Despite the accusations and counteraccusations, Jalali said he does not believe Pakistan wants to remove the Taliban from power. "I do not think Pakistan can or wants to overthrow the Taliban and replace them with another group," he said. He added that Islamabad's aim is to pressure the Taliban to cooperate against the TTP.

Aziz Barez, a political analyst of Afghanistan and regional affairs, said Afghan groups opposed to the Taliban cannot fully trust Islamabad. They may welcome alleged Pakistani support while recognizing it could be temporary. "It is possible that Pakistan and the Taliban will resolve their differences tomorrow and become close allies again," he told DW.

Ahmad Waheed Ahmady and Helay Asad contributed to this report.