Severe flooding in the Four Corners region submerged homes and farms in Shiprock, New Mexico, and damaged wastewater facilities, sending sewage into the San Juan River. Native communities are now working to recover amid concerns about contaminated water and soil, crop losses and limited insurance coverage.
On the night of 23 October, Jimmie Goodman was woken by his sister as authorities warned that the nearby San Juan River could flood. The river surged toward their home, missing it by about 50ft, he said. Goodman and his sister escaped in his pickup after water began filling their driveway.
New Mexico had recorded its hottest summer on record after a dry year, before heavy thunderstorms and rains intensified by this year’s El Niño struck the south-west. Two weekend storms in late October and early November caused once-in-a-generation flooding in the flash-flood-prone region. The San Juan River crested at 21ft near Shiprock, its highest reported level there since 1935, and reached levels not seen across much of the region since 1911.
Floodwaters damaged several wastewater treatment facilities in New Mexico and Utah, causing sewage to enter the river. “The San Juan River is a hazmat situation,” Devin Neeley, a spokesperson for San Juan county, said in late October. “Do not go in the water.”
The flooding affected communities across the Four Corners, where the 27,000 sq mile (70,000 sq km) Navajo Nation reservation spans parts of New Mexico, Arizona and Utah. In Dennehotso, Arizona, emergency personnel rescued elders as old as 102 by raft and helicopter. Near Bluff, Utah, residents were ordered to evacuate and remained hesitant to return weeks later, as E coli levels in the river and surrounding soil measured 25 times the norm.
In Shiprock, Goodman and his sister found temporary housing. Nearby farmers also faced losses as floodwater covered fields. Fiber artist and shepherd Kevin Aspaas said farms in the area grow produce for “all of the communities around the Navajo Nation who don’t have access to this river, who don’t have access to irrigation”. Many crops are “traditional to our communities, and are used in ceremonies”, he said.
Aspaas, who grows beans, melons, squash and corn about a mile from the river, harvested his remaining beans early after seeing the flood reach within a few hundred yards of his crops. Some of his friends lost crops and homes. With sewage in the floodwater, one family “can’t go back into their home”, he said.
“It’s really a biohazard at this point,” Aspaas said, citing concerns about sewage and “about what kind of chemicals they’re using to treat the human waste”. Zachariah Ben of Bidii Baby Foods said E coli and treatment chemicals “are leaching into the soil and will be causing significant problems for future growing seasons”.
Ben also raised concerns about insurance. “Crop insurance doesn’t work the same on tribal trust land” and will “leave Navajo farmers with huge crop and infrastructure losses”, he said. His family is now looking at a $100,000 loss after floodwaters submerged their farm plot, greenhouse and yurt, along with possessions inside.
Local groups and residents have joined relief efforts. Virginia Kirk, who owns the Kirk Center, a rental company and event space in Shiprock, said displaced families were confused about next steps and supporting one another. After the first wave of flooding caused major power outages, “People had no electricity. It was getting cold. They couldn’t cook their food,” she said.
Denisa Livingston, who leads the Diné Community Advocacy Alliance, and Mackee Bancroft, a chef who is Ute Mountain Ute and Diné, began bringing in hot meals. “We are not just people who stepped into the flood response; we are stewards of practicing our ancestral ways of organizing,” Livingston said.
The Kirk Center’s event space became a distribution and donation site. Community members brought items including pet food, diapers and water, while volunteers distributed coal, hay and wood. With support from Turquoise Paws and Soul Dog Rescue, Kirk turned a nearby rental property into a temporary dog shelter. Volunteers with the Kirk Center, the Diné Community Advocacy Alliance and the Red Cross have also distributed meals to evacuees, including Goodman and his sister.
Goodman and his sister are guaranteed housing until 20 November. After that, they will need to pay a deposit to stay in their temporary home for another 60 days. Floodwater has begun to recede at their house, but the road remains impassable. Goodman has returned on foot to feed his chickens.
“It’s hard to rebuild when you have to pay,” Goodman said. He hopes the road to his home will soon be safe to drive on and friends can help him and his sister begin rebuilding.
