A federal judge has ordered the US Army to pause its planned detonation of five tons of lead azide in Middletown, Iowa, after environmental advocates sued over possible effects from the blast.
The Army had planned to destroy 68 drums of the material, which is used to detonate munitions, at the Iowa Army Ammunition Plant in coordination with the US Environmental Protection Agency. The detonation was first scheduled for Friday, then postponed until Monday following objections from residents and elected officials.
Senator-elect Josh Turek said Thursday he had heard from Iowans worried about their health and safety because of potential lead exposure. Lucy Giehl, who lives 4 miles north of the plant, told The Associated Press that the three-day delay had not answered public concerns. “There’s just so many details that I feel like haven’t been addressed with the public,” she said.
In a joint statement Friday, the Army, the Department of Health and Human Services and the EPA said they were working to conduct the controlled detonation “in the safest fashion possible.” The statement said officials had been planning since March and were prepared to take “the most extreme mitigation measures available” to protect the public and minimize disruptions.
The judge’s order does not specify when the court will next act. The EPA said in a court filing that it planned to submit a response by November 22.
Environmental advocates urged state leaders, including Gov. Kim Reynolds, to lead public communication about the proposed detonation. Michael Schmidt, general counsel at the Iowa Environmental Council, said the federal government could not be trusted to adequately inform residents about the risks. “Iowans deserve a transparent, coordinated, and effective response to this unprecedented event,” he said.
Lead azide is a volatile compound that, according to a federal hazardous materials database, can “explode from shock, heat, flame or friction when dry.” The Army said modeling predicted that airborne lead particles could be elevated and that the blast would create a plume of lead-containing particles that could disperse and settle on the ground.
Lead is toxic to the brain, and no level of exposure is considered safe, but the amount that could be released is unclear. Patrick O’Shaughnessy, a University of Iowa professor and environmental health expert, said lead is heavier than air and its spread would therefore be limited. Sizable particles would likely fall within 20 miles of the detonation, he said, while smaller particles could travel downwind toward Iowa City.
O’Shaughnessy said he and colleagues planned to test and monitor the air and ground. The Army also warned that noise and ground vibrations could cause “localized window damage.”
Daren Paul Morris, who walks his dog near the plant daily, told CNN affiliate KCRG he planned to evacuate and was concerned about what he might find afterward. “Hopefully I don’t have any broken windows. I just had the roof replaced,” he said. He also said he would wait for rain before mowing to avoid stirring up dust.
Jen Rowray, who lives in rural eastern Iowa, said she worried about lead’s long-term effects on soil and crops. “We are very aware of how much the soil can be affected by a heavy metal like lead that doesn’t really go away,” she told CNN.
Schmidt cited an Iowa Environmental Council report from March that suggested environmental risk factors may contribute to the state’s cancer prevalence. He also pointed to Muscatine County, about 50 north of the plant, which already has higher lead emissions. “This is just adding another layer of environmental pollution, putting people’s health at risk,” he said.
Rowray said she wanted an outside expert to provide a second opinion and more information about the plume. “As soon as possible doesn’t mean a rush through to where the, the public is losing trust because they’re not getting the right information,” she said.
Environmental advocates said residents received little notice. Schmidt questioned whether the Army’s concern about the instability of the lead azide required an immediate detonation, saying residents received five days’ notice despite the Army having learned of the issue months earlier.
Acting US Army Secretary Adam Telle said the Army found degrading lead azide stored in bunkers at the installation in March and began communicating with stakeholders and residents about the danger. Officials said the Army then developed a safety plan and, after consulting the EPA, experts and the community, determined that a controlled detonation posed the lowest immediate risk.
The Army said the material had become “extremely unstable and sensitive to even slight friction or movement,” making relocation potentially more dangerous. A community flyer said packing and transporting it posed an unacceptable risk of accidental detonation. Telle also said that delaying too long could increase hazards, and that Monday had been the “latest possible moment prior to a forecasted temperature drop,” which could further destabilize the material.
The EPA emergency permit, effective November 13, 2026, through February 11, 2027, authorizes the Army to conduct the detonation during that period. Thien Chau, a senior attorney at Earthjustice, said the permit’s cleanup requirements were inadequate to address the potential impacts and that the extent of the plume and the areas it could affect remained uncertain.
