Lucy Letby’s lawyer has called for the court of appeal to urgently review her convictions after it emerged that a key prosecution medical witness was barred from clinical practice over concerns about patient safety.
Prof Peter Hindmarsh gave evidence at Letby’s trial that two babies had been poisoned with insulin. In March 2023, while the trial was continuing, University College London hospitals trust (UCLH) excluded him from treating patients, citing safety concerns about his care of children in relation to insulin. The jury was not told about the restriction.
Letby’s lawyer, Mark McDonald, has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) for her convictions to be referred back to the court of appeal. He said the revelations and the failure to disclose information about Hindmarsh to the defence “raise fundamental questions” and make a review of the safety of all Letby’s convictions “more urgent than ever”.
McDonald said: “She is an innocent woman in prison, serving whole-life sentences, yet material information that could have been of critical importance to her defence was not disclosed. Did the police know? How did this information remain undisclosed?” He added: “We need answers. Lucy deserves answers. She should not have to spend another day behind bars while these fundamental questions remain unanswered.”
Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others, and sentenced to 15 whole-life terms in prison. Hindmarsh’s opinion about insulin poisoning was considered crucial to the attempted-murder convictions relating to two babies. The court of appeal rejected her applications to appeal.
The Guardian reported that UCLH medical director Dr Tim Hodgson wrote to the General Medical Council (GMC) in March 2023 that, “On the grounds of safety UCLH are not presently in a position to allow Prof [Hindmarsh] to practise clinically even under supervision … I do not believe UCLH can accept the level of risk Prof Hindmarsh appears to pose to children and young people even with close clinical supervision.”
Hodgson cited concerns including two cases in which he said Hindmarsh had advised child patients to stop taking insulin. The GMC sought to suspend Hindmarsh’s medical registration, which he opposed. His barrister argued that suspension would be disproportionate and impede his work as an expert witness.
On 21 April 2023, a medical practitioners tribunal declined to suspend Hindmarsh but ordered that he be directly supervised in clinical work. The article says this appears to have had no practical effect because UCLH had already barred him from treating patients.
Hindmarsh told Cheshire constabulary, which instructed him in Letby’s case, about the GMC investigation in December 2022. The CPS informed the defence but said it would oppose telling the jury. The jury was not told about the investigation, or that Hindmarsh’s contract at Great Ormond Street hospital had ended in July 2022. The defence was also not informed about the March and April 2023 developments.
On 23 February 2023, lead prosecution barrister Nick Johnson KC described Hindmarsh to the jury as “the pre-eminent expert in that narrow field” of insulin. McDonald said it was “staggering” that Hindmarsh had been presented that way while the defence and jury were not told he had been considered unsafe by his own hospital to treat children with insulin and barred from clinical practice.
The CPS confirmed it was never given the information about Hindmarsh’s exclusion from practice. A representative of Hindmarsh declined to answer the Guardian’s questions, including whether he had informed Cheshire constabulary about the March and April developments. The police force declined to comment.
Criminal procedure rules require expert witnesses to disclose information, including disciplinary proceedings, “that might reasonably be thought capable of undermining the expert’s opinion or detract from the credibility or impartiality of the expert”. The rules were introduced in 2014 following Law Commission recommendations aimed at improving expert evidence and guarding against miscarriages of justice.
Two senior lawyers said serious concerns about an expert’s professional abilities and failures to disclose information to the defence could be grounds for an appeal. Tim Green KC said the impact would depend on the facts and the potential weight of the undisclosed information on the jury’s verdict.
Pete Weatherby KC said expert evidence was pivotal in the prosecution because there was no direct or forensic evidence that Letby committed the offences. He said serious concerns about an expert’s conduct or judgment could be significant to an appeal if they were not put before the jury, and that it would be “even more significant” if the prosecution had not obtained and disclosed the full details.
Since Letby’s convictions, dozens of leading UK and international medical and scientific experts have contributed to reports submitted with her CCRC application, arguing that the prosecution’s medical case, including Hindmarsh’s evidence, was wrong.
