Mercedes-Benz’s plan to halt further investment at its German factories and Volkswagen’s decision to shelve a modernization plan for its Wolfsburg plant have intensified concerns about the future of carmaking in Germany. Analysts say the industry needs to shrink and reform, but argue that the moves do not necessarily mark its end.
Mercedes production chief Michael Schiebe said in a written interview for staff that German plants’ running costs are far too high. The automaker is “now forced to carefully examine which German sites we would have to close if we cannot achieve a change in the cost structure.”
Mercedes’ investment halt is linked to negotiations with unions over reducing labor costs at German plants, including scrapping the 35-hour workweek. The freeze could be lifted if the sides reach a deal. Volkswagen, Europe’s largest carmaker, announced its decision about the Wolfsburg plant a day earlier.
Germany’s auto sector faces intense competition from Chinese automakers. Volkswagen is looking to cut 100,000 jobs globally by 2030, and four of its German factories are earmarked for possible closure. Thomas Puls, senior economist for transport and infrastructure at the Cologne Institute for Economic Research (IW Köln), said a third of capacity at German plants is overcapacity and “needs to be cut.” “This will hurt a lot,” he told DW.
A report last month by Munich-based consultancy Roland Berger said German automaking needs an urgent “reset,” while predicting the country could “preserve a sustainably profitable core of automotive value creation.” The sector may become smaller, but more specialized and profitable.
Achim Kampker, an electric mobility engineering professor at RWTH Aachen University, said the investment cuts are more than a negotiating tactic. He described China’s industrial strategy as lightning-fast and Germany’s as “too slow,” citing bureaucracy and complex business structures. “We need to become faster, more innovative and significantly more productive,” he told DW.
According to Roland Berger, Chinese EV-makers can bring a new model to market in around 20 months, compared with 48 to 60 months for German companies, and have a 30% cost advantage. Production costs at German plants are between €3,500 ($3,840) and €5,000 per vehicle, compared with €2,000 to €2,500 in Eastern Europe.
A September report by consultancy PwC said German carmakers are well managed and well capitalized, and know what is coming, but may have a “false sense of security.” It identified four areas for the industry to focus on: separating internal combustion engine (ICE) and electric vehicle (EV) businesses; investing ICE profits in new technologies; redesigning workplace culture and training; and making use of existing partnerships with Chinese automakers and US tech firms.
“The future viability of the German automotive industry depends significantly on decisions made in the next 12 to 18 months,” wrote Harald Wimmer, global and German automotive leader at PwC Germany. He said the industry must also adapt as carmaking becomes part of a larger global electronics sector. Wimmer noted that leading Chinese automakers benchmark themselves against consumer electronics companies, including smartphone maker Xiaomi, which now also produces around 400,000 EVs per year. “Anyone who continues to base their competitive framework solely on their own industry is making a mistake that cannot be corrected once it becomes apparent,” he warned.
German car production remains around 12% below pre-pandemic levels. This year, however, the sector is on course to meet a December estimate of 4.11 million vehicles, 1% lower than last year, according to the German Association of the Automotive Industry (VDA).
Puls said German automakers should avoid the path taken by Italy in the early 2000s, when Fiat struggled with profitability. In Italy, “the politics and the unions blocked any attempt by Fiat to cut overcapacity,” he told DW. “What's the result? They have a capacity of 1.1 to 1.2 million cars and utilization of about 250,000.” Last year, those Italian plants built 214,000 passenger cars, the fewest since 1954, according to the FIM Cisl trade union.
Kampker warned that if German automakers fail to address their shortcomings, “we will see more production sites closing and a substantial shift of industrial investment and employment away from Germany.” He added: “There is still an opportunity to reverse this trend, but the window of opportunity is narrowing.”
