SpaceX’s successful recovery of its Starship rocket last weekend cleared a major hurdle in NASA’s plans to return astronauts to the Moon, raising the prospect of more frequent launches and a long-delayed orbital refueling demonstration next year.

The mid-air catch on Saturday will help SpaceX engineers learn how to reuse Starships quickly, supporting the company’s plans to deploy a new generation of Starlink satellites. NASA expects a higher launch rate to accelerate development of a deep-space Starship for carrying astronaut crews to the lunar surface.

SpaceX plans to open a second Starship launch site at Kennedy Space Center, Florida, early next year. A second factory is also under construction there, alongside the company’s existing production line at Starbase, Texas.

The Starship refueling demonstration has slipped two years since late 2024 as SpaceX worked through technical problems. Saturday’s first-ever catch of Starship at the launch tower may mark a turning point, but key questions remain about the program’s schedule and requirements.

NASA plans several Starship lander tests next year. Artemis III will be followed by an uncrewed Starship landing demonstration on the Moon. Artemis III does not require orbital refueling, while the uncrewed landing will require extensive refueling.

Ars recently spoke with Steve Creech, NASA’s Human Landing System program manager, who oversees the agency’s contracts with SpaceX and Blue Origin to develop crew-rated lunar landers for Artemis.

Under the revised Artemis III plan, NASA will send a four-man crew to low-Earth orbit aboard a Space Launch System rocket and Orion spacecraft. After Blue Origin’s Blue Moon lander launches on a New Glenn rocket, Orion will dock with it for two days of tests. The astronauts will enter Blue Moon’s pressurized cabin to test its environmental control and life support systems.

The astronauts will then return to Orion and undock from Blue Moon before rendezvousing with SpaceX’s Starship in a slightly lower orbit, below most of SpaceX’s Starlink constellation. Orion will remain attached to Starship for two hours, but the crew will not enter the SpaceX vehicle.

NASA changed the Artemis III flight plan earlier this year, shifting it from a lunar mission to one in low-Earth orbit. The program’s first crewed lunar landing is now planned for Artemis IV, targeted to launch before the end of 2028.

Creech told Ars that one reason Artemis III includes more testing with Blue Origin than with Starship is to keep SpaceX focused on orbital refueling. Blue Origin no longer requires in-space refueling for its Artemis landing missions. SpaceX also has extensive life-support experience with its Dragon crew spacecraft, while Blue Origin has comparatively little.

“The bigger challenges for [SpaceX] were the prop transfer and getting to the uncrewed landing demo,” Creech said. “The thing that we’re going to learn more with Starship is, when we dock with Orion, they will have control of the attitude, control of the stack. That integrated stack control will be on the Starship side. So, with that huge of a vehicle, I think we’re going to learn more on that. “With Blue, we’re going to have Orion control the stack for this mission,” Creech said. “When we get to a later mission, the Blue lander with fully loaded prop will have to control the stack. But with Blue, trying to mitigate risk, we’re going to have Orion do that.”

Artemis III will be Blue Origin’s first orbital spaceflight with a crew cabin. The company has flown suborbital space-tourism missions, but those brief flights did not require the advanced life-support systems needed for longer stays. NASA and Blue Origin will focus on those systems during the mission.

“I think SpaceX’s part was really, we need to focus on the docking,” Creech said. “If we added a crew cabin, that would slow us down on the other things and not add to what we’re already doing.”

The Starship used for Artemis III will have a full complement of Raptor engines and a docking port on its nose. Blue Moon will have no main engines when it docks with Orion, only smaller thrusters for pointing control and minor maneuvers.

“With Blue, you don’t have a BE-7 engine, you don’t have the cryo tanks,” Creech said. “They’re representing the mass of the lander when it comes back from the surface because we think that’s the most critical case. But it does have the crew cabin.”

Although Artemis III will not test Starship life support in space, NASA added a milestone to SpaceX’s lunar lander contract for ground testing of parts of its crew cabin. The work includes building a prototype crew compartment, Cabin One, at SpaceX’s test site at Starbase, Texas.

NASA also added test requirements for Blue Origin. After a months-long delay caused by a rocket explosion on its launch pad in May, the company plans to launch its first Blue Moon test mission early next year. The Mark 1 version has one hydrogen-fueled BE-7 main engine; future human-rated landers will have three.

“One of the things we added into the program in the last year is, we really felt like we needed a test of the three-engine configuration,” Creech said. The three-engine Blue Moon propulsion unit will undergo a hotfire test inside a vacuum chamber at NASA’s In-Space Propulsion Facility in Ohio.

This year’s Artemis changes also revised plans for later lunar missions. The new architecture is intended to simplify work for the Starship and Blue Moon teams, though not necessarily for Orion.

“Our previous architecture for both these landers required a 90-day loiter in lunar orbit for Orion to arrive,” Creech said. “That was something that, for both of these landers, drove a lot of complexity, and a lot of it made the lander job really hard.”

NASA says the updated plan removes some of that complexity. “One of the things we changed was that 90-day loiter,” Creech said. “SpaceX, they solved it by saying let’s do an Earth orbit rendezvous with Orion, and take Orion to the Moon. For both Blue Origin and SpaceX, we have updated their requirements to a four-day surface day initially. Before, our initial missions were six-and-a-half days.”

The earlier six-and-a-half-day surface stay was tied to a plan for Orion to enter a long, looping orbit around the Moon called a near rectilinear halo orbit. That orbit was based on the expected location of NASA’s now-canceled Gateway lunar space station, which was in turn driven by Orion’s inability to reach a closer lunar orbit.

Under the new plan, Orion will meet Starship in high-Earth orbit rather than near the Moon. Starship will then propel Orion toward the Moon.

It remains unclear whether SpaceX will need to refuel Starship above low-Earth orbit. A graphic presented last month by Jeremy Parsons, NASA’s Artemis program manager, showed a possible “final tanking orbit” before Starship docks with Orion in high-Earth orbit.

“We’re still working that out,” Creech said. “We’re making progress, but where we actually rendezvous with Orion is still in trade, so that’s why you saw a little bit of fuzziness there.”

For missions using Blue Moon, the lander will meet Orion in lunar orbit. Blue Origin’s revised plan does away with in-space refueling but still requires four New Glenn launches: one for the lander and three carrying transfer stages to boost it from Earth orbit to the Moon.

A new, stretched Centaur upper stage for the Space Launch System is expected to give the rocket enough energy to send Orion to low-lunar orbit, which the current SLS version cannot reach. NASA has not decided whether the new Centaur exploration stage will be ready for Artemis IV. If it is not, the mission could use the last of NASA’s in-stock SLS upper stages.

NASA has also yet to decide which lander will be used for Artemis IV. In either case, two of Orion’s four astronauts will transfer to the lander for a four-day stay on the lunar surface, then take off and return to Orion.

Starship and Blue Moon each must complete an uncrewed lunar landing demonstration before a crewed mission. Creech said the demonstrations are targeted for late 2027 or early 2028, but may not test every capability crews will need to reach the lunar south pole.

Starship’s elevator, for example, is not part of SpaceX’s uncrewed landing demonstration. Engineers will test its performance in a simulated lunar environment at a test lab at Marshall Space Flight Center in Alabama.

NASA initially did not require the companies to demonstrate that their landers could take off from the Moon before a crewed mission. Government officials later added a lunar takeoff requirement to both uncrewed landing demonstrations.

NASA is leaving the details of the uncrewed takeoff tests to SpaceX and Blue Origin. During Apollo, NASA’s lunar lander had not landed on the Moon before Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin descended to the Sea of Tranquility. NASA did fly a dress rehearsal around the Moon on Apollo 10, including a test of the lunar module’s landing-abort capability.

“Where we are today is, Blue will land and then do a full ascent back to the rendezvous point with Orion,” Creech said. “With SpaceX. They will land, they will take off again, get to main stage on the engines, and then they will do another landing on the surface.”

The plan could change. SpaceX’s current approach would give Starship two attempts to demonstrate a safe lunar landing, but it involves tradeoffs.

“When I came into the program, I was like, ‘Why are we not going all the way to the rendezvous point?’” said Creech, who became HLS program manager in 2025. “Some of my key people felt strongly we would get more out of the way we’re doing it now. There are others that have different opinions… We tend to have a lot of technical discussion and debate. That point will continue to be debated.”

Orbital refueling remains essential to Starship’s lunar plans. SpaceX’s propellant-transfer demonstration will use two Starships, one launched from Florida and the other from Texas. They will dock in low-Earth orbit and transfer a “meaningful” amount of propellant, Creech said.

“The first quarter of next year, we will see a long-awaited propellant transfer test from SpaceX, where they launch two Starships in pretty close proximity, actually dock, and transfer, we’re calling it a meaningful amount, of propellant,” Creech told Ars. “That is going to be a big learning point if they pull that off, because their architecture depends on propellant aggregation and multiple propellant flights.”

The test would be the first time one spacecraft has transferred a significant quantity of cryogenic propellants—in this case, methane and liquid oxygen—to another vehicle in space. The results will show engineers how much propellant is lost to boil-off during the transfer, following decades of government and commercial research into cryogenic orbital refueling.

That uncertainty is one reason the number of Starship tanker launches needed for a lunar mission remains unclear. Without refueling, Starships are limited to flights in low-Earth orbit.

The low end of the estimate is six to eight tanker flights, based on figures from Elon Musk, SpaceX’s founder and CEO. That is below NASA’s conservative planning estimate of 20 refueling launches. Musk’s figures depend on future Starship upgrades. SpaceX aims to raise the vehicle’s payload capacity to 100 to 200 metric tons to low-Earth orbit, but Starship V3 remains well short of 100 metric tons.

A fully fueled Starship carries 1,600 metric tons of propellant. Future, fully optimized Starships might be able to fill those tanks with as few as six tanker flights, but that is not possible with the current vehicle.

SpaceX is developing a taller, heavier version called Starship V4, which will fly with nine Raptor engines, compared with the six-engine version flying today. Musk said in 2025 that Starship V4’s first launch was targeted for 2027. There has been no recent schedule update.

Creech said the initial Artemis lunar missions will use Starship V3.