A national effort to have states award their presidential electoral votes to the winner of the nationwide popular vote could reach the 270-vote threshold next year, though political, legal and practical obstacles remain.
Five states expected to be fully controlled by Democrats next year—Arizona, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Nevada and Wisconsin—could join the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact. Together, they have 61 electoral votes. The compact currently has 222 electoral votes from 18 Democratic-led states and the District of Columbia; combinations of at least four of the five states would take it past the 270 votes needed to take effect.
The compact’s member states agree to award their electoral votes to the national popular-vote winner rather than the winner in their own state. No Republican-led states have joined, and the party is largely not unified on the issue.
Governors and incoming governors in Pennsylvania and Nevada have said they are open to signing legislation to join the compact. Other governors have yet to publicly weigh in. Arizona Gov. Katie Hobbs, who previously supported the measure, has not recently commented on whether the state’s new Democratic majorities should sign on. NPR said it sought comment from her office but did not receive a response before publication.
Supporters are optimistic the compact could clear its remaining hurdles, perhaps in time for the 2028 presidential election. Patrick Rosenstiel, a senior consultant to National Popular Vote, told NPR: "I've never been more confident that 63% of American voters can get what they want in the 2028 presidential election, which is a national popular vote for president." He referenced Pew polling.
The five states are presidential battlegrounds, raising questions about whether they would give up their influence in elections ahead of 2028. Their leaders would also have to decide whether to become pivotal in advancing a movement that could change how the U.S. chooses presidents.
Some legal scholars say the interstate agreement could conflict with the Constitution’s compact clause, which says that "no state shall, without the consent of Congress … enter into any agreement or compact with another state … unless actually invaded, or in such imminent danger as will not admit of delay."
Norman Miller, a constitutional law professor at Willamette University, said the compact also presents practical challenges because presidential elections are decentralized: states set their own voting rules, and requiring electors in one state to follow another state’s vote totals could create tension.
"We would want to have a standardized, uniform set of rules regarding who gets to vote for president, how they vote, how those votes are tabulated, and to have a federal election authority doing that tabulation," Miller told NPR. "I think trying to nationalize [the current system] and entrusting a national election to 51 separate election administrators would just sow discord and distrust."
John Koza, chairman of National Popular Vote, said a centralized bureaucracy would not be needed if the compact worked as intended. "We don't need a centralized bureaucracy or a presidentially appointed commission that could be manipulated," he told NPR. "The simple fact is current state and federal law provide for the issuance of a certified vote count from each state. And all that has to be done is add them up."
Miller said a key question is whether such a major change should instead be made through a constitutional amendment. Opponents of a national popular vote, including Save Our States, argue that without the Electoral College’s incentives, politics would move "toward more regional politics and would exacerbate existing divides."
Miller said pursuing an amendment under Article 5 would be more difficult but preferable to working around the Electoral College. "This is where I think process matters," he said. "If you really want to have a national popular vote for the president and avoid all of the legal and practical difficulties, you need to do that through a constitutional amendment, because only a constitutional amendment can address the legal and practical challenges of conducting a national popular vote for the presidency."
A similar effort to pass an amendment abolishing the Electoral College failed in 1969, and few amendments have come close to passing in recent history. Rosenstiel said National Popular Vote and other groups are pursuing a creative solution to what he described as a problem most Americans agree exists.
Rosenstiel said a national popular vote would prompt presidential candidates to appeal to voters across the country rather than focusing on battleground states, and would help voters feel their votes matter. "We should have a system where every American citizen feels valued and is valued when they cast their vote," he said. "And there's only one reform that delivers it."
