Netflix documentary Primetime Preacher$ revisits the rise of televangelism in the United States and the scandals surrounding three prominent ministers: Jerry Falwell, Jimmy Swaggart and Jim Bakker.
Director Joe Berlinger says he initially expected the film to be a break from his true-crime documentaries. Instead, he came to see the growth of televangelism as closely linked to the rise of the religious right. “The deeper resonance for me came when I realized that the global televangelism rise actually mirrors the rise of the religious right,” he says. “Religion and politics, from Reagan on, has really changed politics for the worse in my opinion. This was the birth of that.”
The film traces how televangelism expanded from the early 1970s, when roughly a quarter of US adults identified as evangelical Christians. It also examines the prosperity gospel, which framed personal prosperity as a sign of divine favor and encouraged generous giving to churches and ministers.
Primetime Preacher$ focuses on Falwell, Swaggart and Bakker, whose influence helped shape later televangelists, including Joel Osteen and TD Jakes. Berlinger describes their story as “a fun little Shakespearean tale of ego, greed and ambition” and “a clash of these three men and this bizarre era in history.”
Bakker is at the centre of the 114-minute documentary. Archival footage and interviews with his associates and the Pulitzer prize-winning Charlotte Observer team show how he built a following through a folksy style and television productions that reached more than 13 million people. The film also depicts the luxury lifestyle he and Tammy Faye Bakker funded with church money, including homes, a private jet and facelifts for Jim.
Swaggart publicly attacked Bakker’s PTL ministry, calling him a false prophet. On CNN, he called Bakker “a cancer on the body of Christ”. In the late 1980s, former church secretary Jessica Hahn accused Bakker of rape. It later emerged that she had received $265,000 in exchange for her silence. IRS auditors subsequently concluded that $1.3m in ministry funds had been spent for the Bakkers’ personal benefit. Hahn declined Berlinger’s invitation to be interviewed.
Bakker resigned from PTL and brought in Falwell to manage the crisis and keep donations flowing. Falwell later went public with details of PTL’s financial improprieties, including the Bakkers’ handwritten severance wishlist, and rumors that Bakker may have engaged in homosexual relationships. Falwell eventually left the ministry, which was more than $65m in debt.
Swaggart was also caught in a scandal after declaring he had never had sex outside marriage. He was photographed during a tryst with a sex worker in New Orleans. His televised apology, “I have sinned against you, my Lord!”, was later satirized by Jim Carrey and others. Three years later, Swaggart was caught soliciting again.
The documentary connects the ministers’ scandals to a wider political shift. Bakker, who served almost five years in prison on federal fraud and conspiracy charges, lent his platform to Ronald Reagan after the Federal Communications Commission raised questions about PTL’s fundraising practices. The film describes how evangelicalism became a cornerstone of the Republican coalition and notes that the movement helped elect every Republican president since Reagan, including Donald Trump.
Jerry Falwell Jr appears in the documentary and invokes his father, who died in 2007. The elder Falwell said the scandals had “strengthened broadcast evangelism and made Christianity stronger, more mature and more committed”.
Tammy Faye Bakker is presented as a more sympathetic figure in the film. She gave a platform to gay faith leaders and, after divorcing Jim, became an LGBTQ+ ally. Her son Jay Bakker followed his parents into ministry and embraced a progressive theology supporting LGBTQ+ rights, a stance that created a rift with his father. Jim Bakker died last month.
Berlinger says the film’s central irony is that later televangelists have been more open about seeking wealth. “It’s amazing people give under those circumstances,” he says. “But people want to believe, you know?” Primetime Preacher$ is available on Netflix.
