Prosecutors in Ocala, Florida, allege that Dwain C Hall lured Sonia Exelby from Portsmouth, England, to the US and murdered her. Hall, an auto repair and tow truck driver, has pleaded not guilty to the charges.
Prosecutors say Hall killed Exelby in October 2025 and buried her in a shallow grave in Marion Oaks. Her disappearance prompted an international investigation.
After Hall’s arrest in November 2025, investigators said Exelby had traveled to Florida after posting online about wanting someone to end her life. An arrest affidavit said she had previously expressed suicidal thoughts and alleged Hall knew about her struggles and exploited her vulnerability, the Ocala Starbanner reported.
Authorities said Exelby boarded a flight to the US seemingly with an intention “to be possibly sexually abused, tortured, and murdered by unknown individuals living in the United States”. Prosecutors said Hall picked her up at Gainesville airport and drove her to an Airbnb rental. Investigators later found evidence they say linked him to her disappearance and death, including transactions on her bank cards and a video of Exelby on Hall’s cellphone.
According to the arrest affidavit, a text message from Exelby’s phone to a friend said she felt scared and trapped. “I’m sorry, he keeps taking my phone, he doesn’t trust me with it,” she wrote. “He made it clear there was no way out unless I shoot him.”
In opening statements this week, assistant state attorney Amy Berndt said Exelby had struggled with mental illness and had twice attempted suicide. Berndt said Exelby had visited a website depicting graphic sexual abuse of women, where Hall was among several men who contacted her.
Berndt said Exelby “was trying to find some substitute” to self-harm. “Unfortunately, she found another outlet.” Berndt said Exelby was “trying to find someone who would kill her”. She added: “Unfortunately there was no shortage of depraved men willing to kill Sonia in the most torturous and vile ways possible.”
The court heard that Exelby’s former boyfriend, Stevie Hunt, contacted authorities after she disappeared. Hunt described her as kind, beautiful and loving, and said she experienced mood swings that sometimes lasted for days and had been in therapy for more than a decade. Exelby’s sister spoke about their difficult childhood.
Hall denied killing Exelby but acknowledged in a police interview that he had been in contact with her and that they had been intimate. Evidence prosecutors say links Hall to her death includes a shovel with Exelby’s blood on it, cellphone data, and a knife recovered from a friend of the defendant.
Prosecutors said jurors will be shown photographs and surveillance video of Hall making purchases at a local Walmart, including rope, a shovel, deodorant and other items.
In opening statements, defense attorney Junior Barrett said his client was not a murderer and urged jurors to consider the facts, witness testimony and circumstances of the case. “We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case, you will arrive at the decision that Dwain Hall did not murder,” Barrett said. The case continues.
