At this year’s World Economic Forum meeting in Davos, US President Donald Trump said people from Somalia have low IQs. “I always say these are low-IQ people,” he said in his speech. His son, Donald Trump Jr, made a similar statement about Haitian people in 2024. Trump’s government has since ended the protected status of both Somali and Haitian migrants in the US.

The remarks, write Jonathan R. Goodman and Rebecca Sear of The Conversation, reflect a wider return of racial explanations of human nature in Western politics. They argue that claims of innate intellectual differences between racial groups—sometimes called “race science” or “race realism”—are not supported by sound scientific methods, despite appearing in some academic journals and being used in far-right propaganda.

The authors point to Nathan Cofnas, who drew public attention by accusing the late Jason Arday of plagiarism. They say Cofnas is linked to a network whose members make purportedly scientific claims about racial differences in intelligence, criminality and sexuality. Some are affiliated with universities, which the authors say can give their work an appearance of legitimacy.

Goodman and Sear describe hereditarianism as the view that genetic differences play a key causal role in behavioral and intellectual differences between human groups, rather than environmental factors. They argue that evidence from genetics, evolutionary biology and psychology does not support this account.

They cite evolutionary biologist Richard Lewontin’s finding in the 1970s that genetic variation within human groups exceeds variation between them. The authors say later research supports his conclusions: socially defined racial categories do not map neatly onto genetic clusters, and knowing someone’s race reveals little about their genetics. They also point to ancient DNA research showing extensive mixing between human populations over time.

The article says physical traits such as skin tone, hair texture and the ability to digest milk vary across populations, but are associated with environmental characteristics rather than racial groups. Some genetic variants associated with white skin may have originated in Africa, while milk digestion is found in populations in Europe, Africa and Asia.

The authors also challenge the use of IQ data in race science. They say the “national IQ” database, which claims to provide average IQs for countries, has been repeatedly criticized as methodologically flawed. Different levels of exposure to formal education and cultural differences make intelligence difficult to measure consistently across countries, they write. They cite analysis suggesting low-IQ samples were deliberately selected to represent sub-Saharan Africa, artificially lowering the reported IQ for black populations.

Goodman and Sear note that the Flynn effect—the rise in IQ scores during the 20th and 21st centuries—shows the influence of environmental factors. They add that IQ tests assess specific cognitive abilities, while intelligence is difficult to define and measure and can include abilities such as social intelligence and creativity.

The authors say prominent mainstream accounts of human intelligence do not conclude that racial groups have innate cognitive differences. They point instead to factors including cooperative child-rearing, culture and learning, and argue that human behavioral diversity reflects the ability to adapt to different environments through culture and social learning.

They criticize explanations such as the “cold winters theory,” which claims that harsh winters in Europe and east Asia drove the evolution of greater intelligence after human groups migrated out of Africa. The authors say such accounts make unsupported assumptions and ignore research on human cognitive evolution. They argue that similar environmental challenges occurred as people moved across Africa and that race scientists do not provide archaeological or evolutionary-biology evidence for their claims.

The article places race science in the history of eugenics. In the early 20th century, biologically deterministic explanations of differences between groups, including differences of race and class, were widespread and influential. The authors say such arguments helped justify eugenic sterilization laws and, ultimately, the Nazis’ effort to eliminate people they considered “undesirable.”

After the Second World War, eugenics lost mainstream support and race science was rejected, as advances in biology and genetics showed that human variation could not be neatly mapped onto racial or class categories. The authors say race science nevertheless continued in venues including the journal Mankind Quarterly, which was funded by the Pioneer Fund. They write that the fund supported race science into the 21st century and that its remaining funds were channeled into the Human Diversity Foundation, later rebranded as Polygenic Scores LLC.

According to the authors, race science is generally absent from genetics and evolutionary biology journals, but appears in some mainstream social science and humanities journals as well as in para-scientific publications. They cite psychologist Andrew Winston’s description of the movement as a “community project… with its own networks, mentorships, journals, funding, conferences, heroes, origin myths, martyrs, defenders, and historiography.”

The article discusses the role of academic editors and reviewers in publishing such work, particularly in fields concerned with intelligence, individual differences and evolutionary psychology. It says the journal Intelligence has published a substantial amount of race science and that its editors have defended publication of the work in the name of academic debate.

The authors describe sanctions and institutional responses involving several figures and organizations. Philippe Rushton faced sanctions from his Canadian university but kept his job, apparently following the intervention of Edward O. Wilson. Cofnas retained a postdoctoral fellowship at Cambridge University, although his affiliation with a Cambridge college ended, and kept a postdoctoral position at Ghent University, where some restrictions on teaching were imposed.

University College London acted to prevent further London Conferences on Intelligence on its premises after learning that the conferences had been held there without its knowledge of their subject. Elsevier, publisher of Intelligence, appointed new editors who said they were committed to rigorous and socially responsible science. The authors say race scientists have increasingly published in evolutionary psychology journals instead.

The London Conferences on Intelligence continue elsewhere, the article says. Race science is also promoted through Aporia magazine, whose articles use more overt language and focus more directly on policy. The authors cite an article arguing for eugenics as a solution to Africa’s lack of economic development and claiming that artificial selection for higher intelligence was needed.

The authors say the movement has received funding and support from influential people. A Hope not Hate report found that race scientists received significant funding from US businessman Andrew Conru, who withdrew his funding after the report was released. The US Ambassador to Belgium also intervened when Ghent University investigated Cofnas’s hiring.

Goodman and Sear say race scientists use social media, especially Elon Musk’s X, to circulate their views beyond academia. They argue that academic freedom does not require treating methodologically weak research as a productive contribution to debate, and conclude that race science is pseudoscience. They say it is important to draw attention both to its scientific flaws and to its potential political effects.

Jonathan R. Goodman is Assistant Research Professor, Psychiatry, University of Cambridge, and Rebecca Sear is Director of the Centre for Culture and Evolution, Brunel University of London. The article was republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license.