A jury has found Raelene Polymiadis guilty of murdering her 94-year-old parents with insulin after a four-month trial in South Australia’s supreme court.
Jurors returned unanimous verdicts on Friday after less than five hours of deliberation. Polymiadis, 66, was remanded in custody after her bail was revoked and faces two mandatory life sentences.
The jury accepted that Polymiadis, who has type 1 diabetes, injected Brenda and Lynton Anderson with fatal doses of insulin in separate incidents in March 2022 and April 2023. Both were 94 when they died.
Prosecutors raised the possibility that Polymiadis believed killing her parents would spare them from moving into aged care. Both had declining health and were strongly opposed to the move.
Brenda was admitted to Noarlunga hospital in February 2022 after a fall left her with a fractured vertebra, complicated by pneumonia and another fall. She was recovering and had a discharge plan in place when, after Polymiadis visited on March 12, nursing staff found her “largely unresponsive”. Prosecutors alleged Polymiadis gave her insulin on March 12 and again between March 13 and March 15.
Lynton remained at home after his wife’s death, but became frailer. His four children began taking turns staying overnight. Polymiadis left the house on 30 April, 2023, after spending the weekend with him. A carer found him unconscious two hours later. He died on 1 May from insulin toxicity.
Polymiadis’s former boyfriend Ian Edward Willcourt told the court she had said that “insulin was the perfect murder weapon because it’s natural in the body and it can’t be detected”.
A police listening device recorded Polymiadis alone in her car allegedly confessing to God that she had killed her parents. Police also seized notes written by Polymiadis, including one that said: “What they will do is wait for a few weeks, months, year to see if I ‘think I got away with it’ and I get cocky and slip up. “Hang on buddy, it could be a long ride, otherwise the suspect would be arrested now.”
Justice Sandi McDonald thanked the jury for its service during the “long and difficult trial”. Polymiadis is due back in court on 16 December for a directions hearing.
