The ball-tampering scandal known as Sandpapergate has become an ongoing cycle of outrage and overreaction, Jonathan Horn writes, arguing that the truth probably lies somewhere between competing accounts of the events.

Cameron Bancroft’s 4,000-word essay prompted fresh debate, including calls from SEN’s Gerard Whateley for a comprehensive judicial inquiry “a little bit like a coroner’s inquest”. Cricket Australia’s “forum”, announced hours earlier, had already been abandoned, Horn writes.

Eight years after sandpaper was taken on to the field in Cape Town, Bancroft’s first-person account had offered a new perspective, Horn says. But the story continued to generate press conferences, podcasts, corroborating statements, counterclaims and what he describes as overreaction.

Pat Cummins’ press conference less than a week earlier had been seen by many as the final word. The Australia captain received praise for his performance, while Usman Khawaja’s interview with Sarah Ferguson on ABC’s 7.30 Report drew a starkly different response, Horn writes.

Horn argues that the saga reflects a wider tendency in Australian sport to seek a definitive account and assess people’s character when conclusive evidence is lacking. Judgments can turn on factors including a person’s public speaking, relationship with journalists, skin colour, reputation and state affiliation.

He writes that perceptions can shift rapidly as the story moves between press conferences and podcasts. In his view, the truth probably lies somewhere between a carefully orchestrated scheme involving many people and a poorly planned plot involving only a few.

Horn also discusses remarks by cricket reporter Peter Lalor on his podcast Cricket Et Al, describing Cummins as “an incurious person” who narrows his focus to what he needs to worry about. Horn suggests that some athletes, including Steve Smith and perhaps Cummins, can avoid scrutiny by not seeking to know all the details.

Sporting controversies often begin with intense attention, split into culture-war arguments and then gradually ease through leaks, background briefings and sometimes facts, Horn writes. He compares the coverage of Sandpapergate with recent AFL controversies involving the Sydney Swans at the Pullman Hotel and a Geelong concussion waiver.

Horn says the AFL had a sophisticated public relations and media operation that helped curb coverage of the Swans controversy. News that Victoria police would not charge the four players under investigation emerged during Cummins’ press conference and a global Microsoft Outlook outage.

The Geelong concussion waiver controversy also appeared poised to threaten senior figures in football and change attitudes to head trauma, but then faded, Horn writes. He describes the club and league response as crisis management, and says the AFL’s experience shows how organisations can make stories go away.

Horn argues that Sandpapergate should not have grown as large as it did and that the reactions and reprisals were disproportionate. He concludes that sporting administrators, players and commentators need perspective, warning that otherwise scandals can become a years-long cycle of outrage, judgment and overreaction.