The contest between Chuck Schumer and Chris Van Hollen to lead Senate Democrats has become a flashpoint in the party’s debate over Israel, as Democratic voters’ views of the country shift.
Schumer, the veteran New York senator and current Democratic minority leader, has long been one of Israel’s strongest congressional supporters. He has said his “job” is to “keep the left pro-Israel” and described himself as “Shomer Yisrael”, or “guardian of Israel”. Earlier this year, he said he considers it part of his job to fight for “all the aid that Israel needs”.
Van Hollen, a Maryland senator who has emerged as an advocate for Palestinian rights, has supported sanctions, voted to block weapons sales to Israel and spoken for families of US citizens killed by Israeli soldiers and settlers. He has also opposed the detention of Palestinian children by the Israeli military.
The senators represent contrasting approaches to Israel at a time when a majority of Democrats hold unfavorable views of the country. Van Hollen has repeatedly visited the occupied West Bank. In January 2024, he traveled with Oregon senator Jeff Merkley to the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and Gaza, where they criticized Israel’s restrictions on humanitarian aid.
Schumer has criticized Israeli prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu, calling him a “major obstacle” to peace, but has otherwise been a staunch supporter of Israel throughout his political career. He opposed the Iran nuclear deal, the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement, and a UN resolution affirming that Israeli settlements in occupied territory are illegal. He supported moving the US Embassy to Jerusalem and repeatedly voted against measures to restrict military aid and weapons sales to Israel during the Gaza war.
Schumer did vote for a failed resolution that would have required the state department to report on Israeli human rights abuses in the West Bank, and has backed sanctions on individual settlers. His office did not respond to a request for comment.
In a statement, Van Hollen’s office said: “the Israeli government has become increasingly hardline in its approach, diminishing the possibility of a two-state solution, including through its indiscriminate attacks on Gaza and its complicity in the escalating violence in the West Bank”. The statement added: “The senator has urged the United States to use its leverage to push the government of Israel to comply with US policy and law.”
A Senate leader has wide discretion to set legislative priorities and bring bills to the floor, but would not necessarily control specific votes or foreign policy, particularly during the remainder of Trump’s term.
Van Hollen says his challenge is about delivering the “change from the status quo” that he says drove historic numbers of voters to elect Democrats earlier this month. He has suggested he has the support of 15 colleagues, but five have publicly pledged to back him: Michigan’s newly elected Abdul El-Sayed, Merkley, Vermont’s Bernie Sanders, Minnesota’s Peggy Flanagan and Michigan’s Elissa Slotkin. Others have criticized Schumer and called for change without committing to vote for Van Hollen.
Van Hollen is considered the underdog but says he has a “path” to victory. Whatever the outcome, the campaign has raised his national profile as an advocate for Palestinian rights.
Advocacy groups have also divided over Israel. Bend the Arc, a progressive Jewish group, said: “the midterm elections proved that a majority of Americans are hungry for change and American Jews are no exception”. The Institute for Middle Eastern Understanding’s Policy Project cited Schumer’s record as the only current Democratic senator to vote against the Iran nuclear deal as “paving the way” for the current war in Iran.
“Senator Van Hollen is committed to rights-respecting policy and understands that accountability is necessary to comprehensively challenge impunity,” said Brad Parker, associate director of policy at the Center for Constitutional Rights. He added: “The recent electoral lesson over the past year is that incumbents who ignore the overwhelming and shifting electorate demands to end US complicity in Israeli crimes operate at their own peril.”
Last week, dozens of Sunrise Movement protesters were arrested outside Schumer’s Washington office as they urged him to “step up or step aside”. Schumer, the highest-ranking Jewish elected official in US history, has the backing of much of the political establishment and major pro-Israel groups.
“Jewish Americans have been a critical component of a winning Democratic coalition, including in the 2026 midterms,” said Halie Soifer, CEO of the Jewish Democratic Council of America, which endorsed Schumer. “We’re confident that he’ll lead Democrats to deliver for the American people in a way that is consistent with the values of the Jewish community in the 120th Congress.” Aipac also congratulated Schumer and incoming House speaker Hakeem Jeffries on election night, before Van Hollen announced his challenge.
Democratic officials have shifted their rhetoric more quickly than their policies, the article says. Earlier this year, 103 House Democrats voted to cut military aid to Israel, an unprecedented rebuke that was still less than half the party’s caucus; only one Republican supported it. The Senate has been more cautious.
Van Hollen has tried to focus on other issues since announcing his challenge, but has cited his differences with Schumer over Israel. He accused Schumer of having “joined with Aipac and crypto” to try to defeat El-Sayed. Schumer backed El-Sayed’s Aipac-supported primary opponent, Haley Stevens, but supported El-Sayed in the November general election. In a Fox News interview on Sunday, Van Hollen discussed settler violence in the West Bank and the Israeli government’s complicity. “I don’t think American taxpayer dollars should be going to that purpose,” he said.
“When I first spoke out about Gaza and what I thought – the bad conduct in Gaza – I was a pretty lonely voice, frankly,” Van Hollen said in an interview last year.
When Van Hollen first ran for Senate a decade ago, some Aipac-aligned donors backed him, and he regularly voted with most centrist Democrats on Israel-related matters. He has long been interested in foreign policy, human rights and the Middle East, and has frequently invoked the “Leahy law”, which requires accountability for abuses by US-supported foreign militaries, including Israel’s.
Van Hollen’s criticism of Israel has grown stronger. After Palestinian American journalist Shireen Abu Akleh was killed by an Israeli sniper in the West Bank in 2022, he repeatedly met with her family and pressed the Biden administration for accountability. The article says there has been no accountability and that an official report on her killing remains classified. Van Hollen’s office said the killing “underscored for him the impunity with which the Israeli government was increasingly acting with regard to the West Bank”.
Van Hollen has also advocated for families of other US citizens killed by settlers and soldiers, including Rachel Corrie, Ayşenur Ezgi Eygi and Sayfollah Musallet. He met Mahmoud Khalil, the Columbia University student who became the face of the Trump administration’s crackdown on pro-Palestinian speech, shortly after Khalil was released from ICE detention. After Khalil’s arrest, Schumer said he “abhor[s]” Khalil’s views, while adding that if the administration could not prove he had committed a crime, his speech was protected by the US constitution.
The leadership contest is the latest proxy battle over the future of US-Israel relations. The issue played a major role in mayoral elections in New York and Los Angeles and in Democratic primaries. It is also dividing Republicans and making groups such as Aipac a liability for candidates.
Kidus Girma, campaign director for the Sunrise Movement, told the Guardian that the Senate leadership vote concerned whether the chamber would respond to voters’ calls for change on issues ranging from climate action to getting money out of politics. Support for Palestine, he said, had become “a litmus test issue for Democratic voters”.
