In GTA 6’s Chapter 1 mission “Hey Arnold,” players can kill or spare Arnold after cornering him on a pier. He says he wants to leave the criminal life behind and disappear.

Arnold, Brian’s business partner, has gone missing, prompting the player to track him down. After a vehicle chase and an on-foot pursuit, the player reaches the choice at the pier.

The article describes the consequences as follows: killing Brian earns a Hardened Criminal rating in the Criminal Profile, GTA 6’s morality system, which is based on how often the player kills people. Sparing Brian gives a Restrained rating and contributes less negatively to the profile. Brian will also appear in a later mission if spared, offering extra content.

Players can also wait without choosing; Arnold will leave, producing the same outcome as sparing him. The article says there are no other downsides to sparing him or advantages to killing him.