Apple’s Siri Recap feature for Apple Watch offers privacy safeguards, but a two-week test found its brief summaries could be confusing and unreliable, particularly for longer conversations.

Apple began testing Siri Recap in the watchOS 27.3 beta. The feature lets Series 12 and Ultra 4 Apple Watch models listen to conversations and produce short summaries. The audio is kept separate from apps, Apple and the rest of the operating system, then discarded after a summary is generated.

Siri Recap is still in beta and has not been released. Apple has not finished refining it, and it is expected to become available to the public when watchOS 27.3 launches in December. The test found that some problems might improve before release, while others stem from how the feature is designed.

The feature summarized dialogue from YouTube videos and Instagram Reels, despite being unable to distinguish them from real-life conversations. It also listened to ambient conversations without an indication to people nearby that Siri Recap was active.

Many other summaries covered brief, everyday exchanges that the tester did not want to revisit. Siri Recap can be limited to certain times or locations, which could reduce that issue. It performed best on short interactions, though those were often not useful to keep.

Vet appointments provided a test of longer, more consequential conversations. The summaries were often too concise or inaccurate to help. In one example, Siri combined separate remarks about a cat’s diet and weight into a summary that did not make sense.

Siri Recap does not label speakers. After a vet discussed medication and explained that her own rabbit influenced her choice of a particular brand, the summary confusingly suggested that the tester had a rabbit at home. The article says the blending of unrelated details might be fixable, but the absence of speaker labels is intentional.

A pre-surgery consultation raised another concern: Apple says potentially harmful content is not summarized. The recap omitted parts of the discussion about surgical risks and resuscitation preferences, and did not indicate whether they were skipped because of content filtering or judged unimportant.

Some details were captured accurately. Siri Recap got the date of a follow-up appointment and the exact bill total when spoken aloud. Apple says the feature does not include financial information, leaving the tester unsure what qualifies. Siri also recognized spoken medication names such as benazepril and clopidogrel.

Even when a recap captured major points, the tester worried that rereading it could alter their memory of the conversation. With no full recording to check, Siri decides what to retain and what to leave out. The tester said they would not use or recommend the feature, while also expressing concern about the privacy implications of recording complete conversations.