Justice Sonia Sotomayor said Friday in Philadelphia that she would not be unhappy with term limits for Supreme Court justices, signaling openness to a proposal that could receive renewed attention when Democrats take control of Congress next year.
“As with everything else in life, I wouldn’t be unhappy with term limits,” Sotomayor said at an event hosted by the American Philosophical Society. She described the proposal as an idea “being kicked around very actively.”
Sotomayor, the court’s senior liberal justice, noted that other nations have kept politics out of their judiciaries without lifetime appointments. She first said she would not offer an opinion on the idea, then indicated she was open to supporting it.
Debate over structural changes to the Supreme Court has resurfaced after the midterm election. Many conservatives have warned against proposals that have existed for years. Justice Samuel Alito has repeatedly emphasized the importance of an independent judiciary since the election, without addressing specific proposals.
Public opinion polling shows substantial support for term limits, though many Republicans view changes to the Supreme Court’s structure as an effort to undermine judicial independence. Even with Democrats in control next year, the measure is unlikely to clear the Senate or win support from President Donald Trump.
It is also unclear whether Congress could impose term limits through legislation or whether a constitutional amendment would be required.
“Even though poll after poll shows that most liberals and most conservatives support Supreme Court term limits, I don’t believe a majority of the current justices do, so it’s heartening to hear that Justice Sotomayor appears open to them,” said Gabe Roth, who leads the Supreme Court watchdog Fix the Court.
“After all,” Roth said, “no one in a democracy should serve for 30 or 35 years, as has become the norm, in a position of such power — especially given the unbridled authority the Supreme Court has arrogated to itself this century.”
Sotomayor’s remarks appeared to go beyond comments she made during an appearance at the University of Zurich in 2024, when she openly considered the proposal. According to audio posted by Roth’s group, she said term limits would keep the court’s ideological balance from being “skewed for too long.” She also suggested that federal judges are promised their jobs for life and “that can’t be taken away constitutionally.”
Much of Sotomayor’s Friday discussion looked back at recent high-profile Supreme Court decisions, including those on birthright citizenship and presidential immunity. US Circuit Judge David Tatel, who took senior status in 2022, asked whether the court had lost something because most justices had taken similar professional paths to the bench.
“For sure,” Sotomayor said. “They’ve forgotten that at the center of every case is people.”
