A survey of 20,000 Americans found that 84% of people who had been incarcerated reported being assaulted, shot or stabbed before their first time in jail or prison, according to a report by Just Safe, a victims’ advocacy non-profit.
The nationally representative survey also found that half of respondents who had been incarcerated were hurt by a caregiver as children, while one-third had experienced sexual or intimate partner violence.
Lenore Anderson, president of Oakland, California-based Just Safe, said the findings could prompt the public and elected officials to reconsider crime policy and focus more on trauma recovery services alongside punishment.
“It’s meant to share this very different viewpoint that most people don’t think about: the collateral consequences of victimization,” she said. “We can focus all of our time on how long the sentences are and how challenging the prison environment should be or we can flip the script to ask: ‘What happened and did people get help?’”
The report describes how some people who do not receive trauma recovery services cope with lingering pain, including by using drugs and alcohol or by hurting others in ways similar to how they were harmed. The report said both paths can lead to repeated contact with the justice system and increase future risk of violence.
“Hurt people hurt people,” Anderson said. “This data is also screaming out that hurt people hurt themselves first. They’re showing up in our justice system for things related to substance abuse.”
Jemaine Hunter said the findings reflect his experience. He grew up in Fresno, California, and faced violence from some family members as a child and young teen. By age 13, he was getting into fights with young men in his neighborhood.
“I was probably a victim in every situation possible. Things have been stolen from me, I got into fights that I didn’t win,” he said. “But it wasn’t my fault that things happened to me.”
Hunter also witnessed people being shot and killed when conflicts escalated. He said he decided to do what he could to avoid the same fate.
“Hearing those stories made me say, ‘I don’t wanna be a victim.’ It was the homeboys being killed that made me feel like I needed to keep a gun and be ready to use it all the time,” Hunter said.
At 24, after being in and out of juvenile detention as a teen, Hunter was convicted of attempted murder and sentenced to 34 years to life in prison. He served 23 years in California prisons, including San Quentin in northern California, and was released in December 2025. He now works as a counselor for Sunset Youth services, a San Francisco-based non-profit supporting young people who have been repeatedly arrested or are on probation.
While at San Quentin, Hunter co-founded Arms Down, a first-in-the-nation support group for people convicted of gun offenses. He heard accounts from men who had been jumped and abused, then joined gangs and carried firearms to feel safe. Hunter said many lacked protection from violence, a place to process what had happened to them and mentorship to help prevent them from repeating violence.
“As a kid I needed that superhero and someone who would stand between me and that fear. Someone to say: ‘Hey man, back up. Don’t touch him’ and bring that ear and shoulder to lean on,” Hunter said.
The report recommends training first responders, nurses and teachers to refer people to assistance services. It also calls for municipalities to invest more in trauma recovery and remove bureaucratic barriers to victims’ compensation.
“If we’re committed to public safety we have to ask what stops the cycle and that looks different from what our current criminal justice system does,” Anderson said. “It means ensuring that what happened never happens again through accountability measures that allow people to address underlying drivers.”
Hunter teaches the Arms Down curriculum to young people in San Francisco who carry guns. Many have been jumped or lost a friend to violence. He said he hopes the model developed by Sunset Youth Services will be replicated in cities across the country.
“What’s going on in San Francisco is beautiful and a blessing for these young men and women who are going through trauma,” Hunter said. “These community-based organizations deserve a round of applause and they’re doing something that the country can mimic.”
