Telegraph staff have raised concerns about the title’s direction under Axel Springer, with insiders saying they have seen cuts but no clear long-term strategy since the German media company bought it for £575m earlier this year.
The concerns have been sharpened by the departure of deputy editor Rob Winnett, who is joining the Daily Mail as chief content editor. Winnett led the Telegraph’s coverage of the MPs’ expenses scandal and had been part of a team that travelled to Florida to explore a base for an expanded US operation. Solid plans for that expansion have not emerged.
Rumours about the leadership circulated this week after days of meetings between senior figures. Speculation focused on editor Chris Evans and Winnett, and was fuelled by Evans’s apparent early return from a trip to the US. Evans remains in the newsroom; Winnett is leaving.
Axel Springer and its chief executive, Mathias Döpfner, bought the Telegraph titles earlier this year, promising investment and expansion. Five months into the company’s ownership, insiders say they have seen cuts and no discernible long-term strategy. One staffer said: “I don’t think they have a particular plan – they clearly want money saved,” adding that Evans had been given a savings target and that “it’s all very vague” in terms of a plan.
Winnett’s departure was described by one insider as “a huge loss”. It follows a town hall meeting with the Telegraph’s chief executive, Carolin Hulshoff Pol, where reporters said questions about the cuts and the company’s plans went unanswered. Large numbers of employees, including senior newsroom figures, have been told they are being made redundant.
Hulshoff Pol said the strategy was to reinvent the reader experience, build new revenue streams and grow internationally. Staff have sought details about the company’s ambition to become a “global, AI-powered premium media and intelligence business” and remain unclear about what the use of AI will entail.
The departure and redundancies have also raised questions about who is making the cuts. Evans kept the Telegraph operation going during three years without an owner, when it could not make major strategic decisions. He now appears to have been tasked with making cuts for Axel Springer. Some believe he is being used to carry out “the bulk of the current bloodletting”. A source said the company was taking “difficult proposals that we believe are necessary for the future of the business”.
Some staff initially thought the purchase might bring a political shift towards a global centre-right audience, pointing to the loosening of ties with Reform’s Nigel Farage and the departures of rightwing writers including Allison Pearson and Sherelle Jacobs. Many now believe the changes have been driven more by costs than politics. The Telegraph’s new US podcast, The Right Track with Poppy Coburn, most recently featured rightwing media host Steve Bannon, an ally of Donald Trump.
Staff had expected Axel Springer to invest, while insiders say its executives appear focused on boosting advertising. The cuts are taking place despite the Telegraph making underlying profits. Media analyst Alex DeGroote said: “This is a business that generates healthy margins, healthy profits,” and said that, at face value, the redundancies were not due to financial pressures. He added that the scale of the restructuring suggested “a deep strategic rethink” and said: “Basically, I’m afraid it points to AI.”
Döpfner’s broader media ambitions have added to staff uncertainty. He made an unsuccessful bid for the Financial Times in 2015, later bought Business Insider and Politico, and has expressed interest in the Wall Street Journal. It had been assumed he would use the Telegraph to compete against right-leaning media in the US. Recent reports said he was interested in acquiring a stake in TikTok’s European operations and had discussed the idea with the US ambassador to France, Charles Kushner, in January.
One journalist at the town hall asked: “It’s all very well getting rid of the people that come in with stories and write them and produce them and present them to you on a plate, but what are you then going to do? You don’t get a room full of journalists together and not have answers.”
