A Texas execution that took 63 minutes and saw prisoner Reinaldo Dennes scream in pain has renewed calls for a nationwide moratorium on lethal injections. State officials said the execution followed protocol and was successful.
Dennes, 70, was pronounced dead at Huntsville penitentiary on Thursday night after the execution team struggled to find a vein for the pentobarbital. His spiritual adviser, the Rev Jeff Hood, said Dennes fought against the pain and pleaded for it to end.
Hood recounted Dennes shouting, “The pain!” and saying his leg was “on fire”. In his account, he also quoted Dennes as saying: “It’s not working like it’s supposed to. Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. What is going on? Fuck. Fuck. Fuck.” Hood said Dennes continued praying throughout the ordeal.
The execution has been compared with the failed execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee, who in September became the only person ever to survive a full dose of execution drugs. In both cases, staff struggled to establish intravenous lines, and the prisoners reported severe pain and burning sensations, according to the article.
“The world saw what happened to Christa Pike, and now to Mr Dennes,” said Robin Maher, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center. “The question now is, how many more of these botched executions will be tolerated by the American people?”
Maya Foa, chief executive of Reprieve, called for a moratorium on lethal injections. “Lethal injection is torture – and Reinaldo Dennes was not sentenced to be tortured,” she said. “Even the most ardent supporters of capital punishment must recognise that the dominant method of execution in the US is broken and cannot be allowed to continue.”
The Texas Department of Criminal Justice disputed the characterization of the execution as botched. Spokeswoman Amanda Hernandez told the New York Times: “as far as this agency is concerned, it is 100 percent not a botched execution. This was a successful execution, and we did follow all of the proper protocols to do it correctly.”
Dennes was convicted of capital murder in the 1996 killing of Janos Szucs, a diamond dealer who was shot in Houston.
The article says Texas obtains pentobarbital from compounding pharmacies after an international boycott, and that the state keeps its procurement and storage practices secret. Lawyers for condemned prisoners have argued that the drugs may vary in quality and can be kept beyond their expiration dates.
Jonathan Groner, an expert on execution methods and emeritus professor of clinical surgery at Ohio State University, called lethal injections a “medical charade”. He said the IV lines in Dennes’s foot and shoulder suggested the team was struggling, and argued that executions take place without the equipment and skills used in hospitals.
The article also says Texas’s execution practices may face renewed scrutiny after midterm election changes, including Democrat Gina Hinojosa winning the governor’s mansion and Democrats flipping 20 state House seats. It says Democrats also won all seats up for election in the Texas supreme court and court of criminal appeals.
