A report that Maldon uses imported German rock salt in its Essex production has prompted criticism, but food writer Thea Everett argues that the source makes little difference to the finished salt.
The Observer reported this week that Maldon, known for its flaky salt, uses German rock salt at its Essex plant. It has since emerged that Cornish Sea Salt also imports European salt for production. The Observer report said “tonnes of mined rock salt are being poured into the production line” at Maldon.
The criticism centres on the brands describing their products as sea salt, which is made by evaporating seawater, while rock salt is mined from underground deposits formed from ancient seabeds. Everett writes that salt makers combine different types to produce salt, and says she considers this a relatively minor transgression in food manufacturing.
“Posh salt” has grown in popularity over the past half-century. Major supermarkets began selling Maldon sea salt in the early 00s, and the rise of chef-inspired home cooking has helped make flaky salt increasingly popular over the past 20 years.
Everett points to celebrity cooks and food personalities who have promoted flaky salt, including Nigella Lawson, who said she “always [has] a pinch pot of Maldon in [her] purse”, and Molly Baz, who regularly pours it from the packet on her YouTube channel. Salt Bae also became known for sprinkling flaky salt on steak. Home cooks now use it on dishes including porridge, chocolate mousse and ice-cream.
The size of salt crystals affects how salt behaves in food, Everett writes. Table salt can seem saltier because its smaller grains mean more salt fits into a teaspoon than flakes do. Flaky salt is valued for its texture and for how easily it can be crumbled between the fingers, allowing precise seasoning.
Everett argues that salt is ultimately sodium chloride (NaCl), whether it comes from Essex estuaries, German mines or Mexico. She says neither rock salt nor sea salt is more refined, and that, apart from sulphurous black salt from the Himalayas, a blind taster would not be able to identify a salt’s country of origin.
Unlike cheese, olive oil or coffee, Everett writes, salt’s provenance does not determine its flavour. Its production method shapes whether it forms chunky rocks, thin flakes, pyramids or tiny grains. Once processed, she says, a salt’s characteristics do not reveal where it came from.
Everett uses table salt for bread, stocks, stews and other dishes where a large amount will dissolve, and saves Maldon for finishing dishes, vegetables, salads and desserts. She says she buys 1.4kg tubs of Maldon for £15 from an Italian wholesaler in Croydon, while Halen Môn’s Welsh salt retails at £32.50 a kilo. She says the finished products taste pretty similar.
Everett compares the Maldon controversy to losing interest in a favourite band after it releases a more mainstream third album. She says the company should declare its product’s provenance, but adds that she will continue buying Maldon, which she describes as the cheapest flaky salt available to her.
Thea Everett is a London-based food writer who runs a recipe Substack called What’s That You’re Cooking, Thea?.
