Margaret Sullivan argues that Donald Trump’s response to a series of technology outages has done little to reassure the public, amid questions about what caused the disruptions and whether they were connected.
In less than a week, Microsoft went down, the FAA grounded all flights, banking systems were roiled, and the National Security Agency’s internal network failed. Sullivan asks whether these were random coincidences or signs of a broader digital threat.
She says that in normal times, Americans would expect the president and administration experts to provide clear answers, explain what they did not yet know, and outline how they were investigating. Instead, Sullivan writes, the public has reason to distrust the administration’s statements.
Trump declared that everything was fine or blamed Joe Biden and former transportation secretary Pete Buttigieg for problems. Current transportation secretary Sean Duffy offered explanations for the nationwide grounding of flights, first citing overloaded switches and then the conversion of copper to fiber-optic equipment at a remote facility. Dozens of air-traffic controllers disagreed with Duffy’s explanations, Sullivan notes.
Sullivan cites Trump’s record of falsehoods, including his refusal to admit that Joe Biden won the 2020 election. She also questions Trump’s remarks to reporters in the Philippines about the outages: “It’s life … When you’re big and powerful and you have all the money, things like that happen, it’s fine.”
The column contrasts Trump’s response with analysis from cybersecurity expert Nicole Perlroth, formerly a New York Times cybersecurity reporter. Perlroth responded to a Washington Sun report that Wall Street executives and the NSA had told Congress the outages resulted from efforts to quickly fix vulnerable systems identified by AI, overwhelming networks during the rush to patch them.
Perlroth wrote: “We are now entirely dependent on software systems that almost nobody understands end to end, that increasingly few people can repair, and that attackers can now probe at machine speed,” and described “a period of unprecedented technological instability … a period of cascading failures, whether triggered by attackers, bad updates or our own accumulated complexity.”
Sullivan says Perlroth’s assessment goes beyond Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s assurance that the outages are “not inter-related”. While malicious actors did not seem to be involved, Sullivan argues that the breakdowns are connected in a broader sense and form part of a pattern fueled in part by AI’s growing capabilities. Margaret Sullivan is a Guardian US columnist writing on media, politics and culture.
