Two-thirds of Americans said the recent midterm elections were “free and fair,” up from 49% who expected the vote to be fair before the election, according to a nationwide poll by UC San Diego’s Center for Transparent and Trusted Elections.
The poll also found that Americans favor state and local control of elections over federal control by a 3-1 margin. Support for local and state control was reported by 78% of Democrats, 62% of independents and 52% of Republicans.
The increase in confidence was largest among Democrats. Before the Nov. 3 election, 55% said they expected the midterms to be free and fair; afterward, 93% said they were. Among independents, the share rose from 43% to 66%. Republicans’ confidence fell from 55% before the election to 46% afterward.
The pollsters said partisan views remained prominent, but described the drop in Republican confidence as “muted” compared with the increase among Democrats. They also said the gains among Democrats and independents were greater than normal.
Lauren Prather, a co-director of the center, said the relatively small decline among Republicans may be because “it had already declined quite a bit.” She also pointed to Trump, Republican leaders and losing Republican candidates quickly accepting their losses after the election, “even though Trump has since walked that back.”
Prather said Democrats’ “overwhelming victory makes it hard to really challenge the results in a way that has been done before.” She added that it becomes “more difficult to sell a story about the election being rigged when you don’t also have the actual candidates that lost trying to challenge or trying to corroborate that narrative.”
Thad Kousser, the center’s other co-director, said Democrats’ “off-the-chart” increase in trust likely reflected both their party’s sweeping wins and the fact that concerns about possible federal interference did not come to fruition. “They had a whole host of other concerns: Would the federal government intercede in the election, would it be seizing ballots, would there be ICE at the polling places?” Kousser said. “Well, that didn’t happen.”
Before the election, Trump alleged without evidence that Democrats would cheat to win. Since then, he has alleged, again without evidence, that they did cheat. The article says the president has made baseless election-fraud allegations for years.
Before the midterms, Trump issued election-related executive orders seeking nationwide mail-ballot, voter ID and proof-of-citizenship requirements. The U.S. Postal Service tried to impose its own vetting process on mail ballots. The Justice Department sued states over voter rolls in an effort to purge alleged noncitizen voters, and sued California and Los Angeles County in an attempt to block 20,000 ballots it alleged could be from noncitizens. Federal courts blocked all of those efforts.
Democrats and election officials in California fought the federal efforts and later described the midterms as a relatively uneventful success. In Los Angeles County, officials said investments in election infrastructure and staffing helped them count millions of ballots faster than in the past.
The poll found differing views on how much political leaders discuss election fraud: a majority of Democrats said leaders talk about it too much, while more Republicans said they talk about it the right amount or not enough. “Republican leaders, political leaders, might find a receptive audience in their base in future years for this,” Kousser said.
Respondents also raised concerns about artificial intelligence’s role in the midterms and about election insiders betting on political race outcomes on prediction markets.
The poll surveyed 3,430 American adults from Nov. 9 to 16 and had a margin of error of plus or minus 1.7%.