Australia’s national security laws watchdog has recommended removing religion from the legal definition of terrorism, saying the reference has given accused terrorists “false credibility” and contributed to discrimination and violence against religious minorities.

The Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM) report, released Thursday, reviewed Australia’s definition of terrorism over the past 25 years. The watchdog also recommended separating credible terrorist threats from actual acts and limiting the maximum sentence for making a terrorist threat to five years.

The current federal criminal code definition requires agencies to prove an act was intended to cause serious harm to people or property to advance a political, religious or ideological cause. INSLM head Jake Blight said religion should instead be treated as an example within a broader “ideology” category.

“Having a law that requires proof that terrorists were advancing a ‘religious’ cause gives these terrorists false credibility and reinforces their narrative that they are doing holy work,” the report said. “The same individuals will still be able to be prosecuted, but should be described as violent ideologues.”

The report said references to religion had “contributed to discrimination and violence against religious minorities, especially Muslim Australians” and negatively affected social cohesion. It said removing religion as a primary motivation was in line with international best practice.

Australia’s special envoy to combat Islamophobia, Aftab Malik, said in a submission that retaining religion as a terrorism motivation created a “climate of suspicion” around Muslims and “provided ammunition for far-right extremist narratives”. Eleven Muslim advocacy and community groups, including the Australian Muslim Advocacy Network, welcomed the recommendations and urged the government to amend the laws.

The Executive Council of Australian Jewry described the report as “high-quality” but argued that removing religion as a motivating factor made “little sense when so many notorious terrorist acts have featured motifs, words and images that unmistakably refer to religious doctrines and beliefs”.

The organisation’s co-chief executive, Peter Wertheim, said: “The inclusion of ‘faith’ as a type of ideology does not solve the problem. Faith is not the same as religion and religion is more than an ideology.” He added: “It is clearly not appropriate for Australian law to decide which beliefs are an authentic expression of a religion and which are not. Even the adherents of a religion may have divergent views about such matters.”

Under current laws, a person convicted of making a credible terrorist threat can receive life imprisonment, with a mandatory minimum sentence of six years. The INSLM called the penalty “disproportionate, unnecessarily complex and out of step with international standards” and recommended a separate offence carrying a maximum sentence of no more than five years.

The watchdog also recommended raising the threshold for classifying damage to property and electronic systems as terrorism, while excluding advocacy, protest, dissent and industrial action.

The report comes as the Australian Federal Police and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation warn that rising violent nationalism has changed the threat landscape. In an October submission to a parliamentary inquiry into radicalisation, Asio said around 65% of its counter-terrorism caseload related to religiously-motivated violent extremism and 35% to ideologically-motivated extremism.