The direction of a person’s finances may matter more than their current income when they consider having children, according to the 2026 American Family Survey, released Thursday by Brigham Young University and the Deseret News.
Among childless adults under 50, 44 percent of those whose finances improved over the past year said they definitely wanted children, compared with 24 percent whose finances worsened. By income, the figures were 29 percent for people earning under $50,000 and 32 percent for those earning $100,000 or more.
“Whether your finances are going up or down tells people more about the future than does your income now,” said Andrew Cherlin, a professor emeritus of sociology at Johns Hopkins University who studies family formation and wasn’t involved in the survey.
The annual survey has been conducted since 2015. This year, YouGov surveyed 3,000 Americans and an additional 1,500 adults ages 18 to 40.
Young adults were more likely than older Americans to say they wanted certain conditions in place before having a baby, including financial stability, an established career or a house. Higher earners listed more conditions on average.
“Income just doesn’t determine all of this,” said Jeremy Pope, a political scientist at BYU and one of the survey’s authors. “But I do think people care about security, they just define it differently depending on their situation.”
Because parenthood is a long-term commitment, people “want to feel certain that the conditions they need to actually raise children for 18, 20, 25 years will be in place,” Karen Benjamin Guzzo, director of the Carolina Population Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, told me.
About a third of childless adults under 40 who wanted children said they could not say when, or whether, they would feel financially ready. That share remained around 30 percent from people’s late 20s through their late 30s.
The survey found that people whose finances had worsened were least likely to say they definitely wanted children, while those whose finances had improved were most likely. Pope said more research is needed, but suggested people may think about their financial prospects when considering parenthood: “I do think small changes make a difference to what you believe about the future.”
The survey does not establish that concern about the future keeps people from wanting children. Melissa Kearney, an economist at the University of Notre Dame who studies birth rates, said the results “could also be showing that people who want kids are more likely to [be] on a positive financial trajectory, and people who don’t want kids are subject to more uncertainty or downside financial risk.”
Pope said he thought that explanation was less likely but could not rule it out. He also noted that the survey records what people say they want, which may not predict what they do. “It doesn’t mean you’re out there buying prenatal vitamins or something,” he said.
In a list of eight possible prerequisites for a first child, financial stability was the most commonly selected by adults under 40, at 68 percent. Young adults were more likely than people over 40 to say they needed an established career first (48 percent versus 32 percent) or a house (30 percent versus 20 percent).
Young adults earning $100,000 or more selected an average of 3.9 conditions they considered extremely important to have in place before having a child, compared with 3.3 among those earning under $50,000. Cherlin said that for wealthier young adults, having a child is “something you only do when the rest of your life is in order.”
People with higher incomes worry less about providing children with basic needs, Cherlin said, “but they are concerned about whether they can maintain their middle-class lifestyles.” Kearney said higher earners “might simply have an even higher bar for what they need to feel economically secure or sufficiently ‘ready’ to bring children into their lives.”
In a forthcoming paper, Kearney and her co-authors found that never-married, childless adults in their late 20s and early 30s did not rate a hypothetical life with children more favorably when it also included ample finances or a home. They did rate it more favorably when it included a fulfilling relationship.
“While income and prices still matter, something beyond income and prices is driving the generational shift that we’re witnessing in the family formation decisions of young adults,” Kearney said.
Financial hardship was also common in the survey. Forty-two percent of respondents said they had faced a serious financial hardship in the past year, such as going hungry, missing an important bill or skipping medical care because of cost. That was up from 35 percent last year and the highest share since the survey began asking about hardship in 2016.
Among adults ages 18 to 40 earning under $50,000, nearly two-thirds reported a hardship, about double the rate among those earning $100,000 or more. Pope cautioned against drawing strong conclusions because the survey changed how it asked about hardship this year. He said he was “not prepared to lean terribly hard on that data” until another year of results is available, though he believes hardship has been rising since the pandemic.
Guzzo said financial pressures frequently come up in her research with childless young adults, including “the general cost of living, the cost of housing, the cost of childcare, the level of debt people have, [and] having a stable job that pays decently.”
Childcare costs have already affected family decisions, the survey found. Half of parents with a child under 12 said they had made a sacrifice because of childcare costs, such as cutting back on work, quitting or turning down a promotion. Fifteen percent said they had delayed having another child.
Pope said childcare is often the most pressing issue for parents of young children. He also said people may have learned not to rely on government assistance after pandemic aid ended. “Sometimes the government gives money and sometimes it doesn’t, and people see that we can’t necessarily count on that,” he said. A permanent childcare program, he added, is something “people would think they can rely upon.”
The article argues that policies offering lasting security — including more affordable homeownership, permanent childcare assistance and federal paid family leave — may do more to help people feel ready to start families than temporary measures such as the one-year expansion of the child tax credit or pandemic-era stimulus checks. It also says persistent inflation, tariffs and the Iran war have combined to lower Americans’ real wages this year, while uncertainty about workers’ place in the AI era may affect how they view future earnings.
Having a child, Pope said, is “in a sense a forever commitment.” People weigh decisions differently depending on how long they last, he said, “and policymakers should think about family supports in the same way.”
