The butterfly has returned as a prominent fashion motif, embraced by pop stars and brands and taking on new meanings for Gen Z, including resilience, girlhood and anxiety about the future.

In a Gucci campaign, Mariah Carey appears at a Christmas party in a fake fur coat and azure dress. Butterflies, associated with Carey since her 1997 album Butterfly, feature in the campaign and have recently re-emerged as a symbol of Gen Z defiance and girlhood.

Other performers have also worn butterfly designs. Janelle Monáe wore a Robert Wun couture gown with wide, yonic wings at the Academy Museum gala in October. Tate McRae wore a black sequined butterfly bra and matching wing belt by Ludovic de Saint Sernin, while Zara Larsson and her fans have championed glittery butterfly makeup.

The motif has spread to fashion retail. Balenciaga collaborated with Damien Hirst on butterfly designs for the 25th anniversary of its Le City bag, referencing Hirst’s In and Out of Love exhibition, where live butterflies hatched inside the show space. Urban Outfitters sells butterfly-patterned items including trinket trays, duvets, cushions and hair clips.

Stylist Caterina Ospina, who has worked with Larsson on the Australian and Asian legs of her world tour, sees the revival as a backlash against growing up. The butterfly has also carried erotic associations: designers such as Versace and Mugler used it in the 1990s. “And although the butterfly isn’t primarily a sexual symbol, it functioned as one for them,” says Dr Valerie Steele, an expert on fashion symbolism and director of the Museum at the Fashion Institute of Technology.

Later in the 1990s, Carey, Britney Spears and Destiny’s Child helped make the butterfly a symbol of girlhood and coming-of-age. “At the time I was writing Butterfly, I was going through my own personal metamorphosis,” Carey told the writer in 2022. “After that, I grew into becoming a free, emancipated person. People call me ‘butterfly’ instead of ‘Mariah’”.

Steele says the butterfly has carried “layers upon layers” of meaning. In Greco-Roman times it symbolised the soul; in the 18th century, painter Thomas Gainsborough used it as a portrait of innocence, with his daughters chasing one. In the 1960s, Times editor William Rees-Mogg criticised the prison sentence given to Mick Jagger and Keith Richards after the Redlands drug raid, asking in an editorial: “Who breaks a butterfly on a wheel?”

Kyle Raymond Fitzpatrick, who writes the Trend Report culture newsletter, connects the current Gen Z revival to unease about global instability and climate change. “It’s about future-anxiety. Mourning the future you’re never going to have, in the present,” he says. “Nature is disappearing and we are more cut off from it. Like ‘remember when there were butterflies?’” He says wearing the motif can be “a form of activism”. The article reports that 80% of butterfly species in the UK have declined since 1970.

Elle Fanning wore baby pink and white Valentino couture with butterfly-adorned gloves and hat last month, referencing a McQueen butterfly dress worn by her character Effie Trinket in the original Hunger Games films. The same week, Jennifer Lawrence invoked her Hunger Games character Katniss Everdeen’s three-finger salute to encourage fans to vote in the midterms.

Nicky Zimmermann, creative director of the Australian boho brand, featured “hive”-like butterfly tops and denim “butterflies” emerging from jeans in its spring/summer ‘27 collection. “It wasn’t about the delicacy,” she says. “It was about resilience.”

Emma Butler of charity Butterfly Conservation says butterflies evoke “images of sunshine, the warmth and colour of flowery meadows and gardens teeming with life”, adding: “And of course there is also the undeniable truth that they are just beautiful insects.”