Chelsea’s recent results and statistics have strengthened the case that injured striker Joao Pedro may be the club’s most important player. He will miss Leeds United’s visit on Saturday with a thigh injury.
Chelsea have lost three of their previous four matches without the Brazil forward, although one defeat came in a penalty shootout against Liverpool in the Carabao Cup. The run also includes a 1-0 loss to Sunderland and a 2-0 home defeat by Tottenham.
Manager Xabi Alonso has faced criticism over Chelsea’s lack of identity and his choices for replacing Joao Pedro. Danny Welbeck, expected to provide cover after arriving from Brighton in the summer, has started only one Premier League match during the striker’s absence. Pedro Neto has twice played through the middle, while Morgan Rogers started as the central striker against Spurs. Emmanuel Emegha, signed from Strasbourg over the summer, has not started a league game and has also had fitness issues.
Fifth-placed Chelsea are already 11 points behind Premier League leaders Arsenal. The club regard their £55m signing from Brighton in 2025 as a key figure in Alonso’s plans; he was given a new contract until 2034 and the number nine shirt vacated by Liam Delap in August.
Asked on Friday about scoring more goals without Joao Pedro, Alonso said: "Yes, we need the whole team for that. It's not just the strikers who can score, we can score in set-pieces from defenders, midfielders, so it's teamwork for sure. "Joao is an important player but we need to be this time without him. So far we have tried different options and we need to keep trying. I think that there are more explanations for one defeat than missing just one player. "The other players, they need to step up and they need to show that they are ready to compete and ready to play for Chelsea."
Since the start of the 2025-26 Premier League season, Chelsea have averaged 1.8 goals per game with Joao Pedro and 0.6 without him. Their expected goals average falls from 1.8 to 1.1, while their shots on target average drops from 4.8 to 3.9.
Chelsea have failed to score in 12.2% of Premier League matches involving Joao Pedro, compared with 71.4% when he has been absent. They have lost without scoring in 7.3% of league games featuring him, compared with 71.4% without him. Three of their Premier League defeats this season came without him, while they have scored in every game he has played. Chelsea’s points-per-game average falls from 1.5 to 0.9 when he is unavailable.
Joao Pedro has also played as a number 10 and on the wing. In the past season and a half, Cole Palmer has played 2,317 Premier League minutes alongside him and 528 without him. Palmer has scored 12 goals and registered four assists with Joao Pedro in the side, equivalent to 0.6 goal involvements per 90 minutes. Without him, Palmer has one goal and no assists, or 0.2 goal involvements per 90.
Palmer creates more chances when Joao Pedro is absent, averaging 1.9 per 90 minutes compared with 1.4 alongside him. His goals return, however, falls from 0.5 per 90 to 0.2. Joao Pedro has assisted four Palmer goals, while Palmer has assisted three goals by the former Brighton forward.
There is less data for Rogers because he joined more recently. He has played 523 Premier League minutes alongside Joao Pedro and 360 without him. With Joao Pedro available, Rogers averages 0.7 goals per 90 minutes and 0.9 goal involvements per 90. Without him, his goal involvements fall to 0.3 per 90. The sample size is relatively small, but the figures suggest Chelsea’s attacking players generally produce more when Joao Pedro plays.
All three of Joao Pedro’s assists this season have been for Rogers or Palmer. The trio prompted early-season excitement, with nicknames including 'JP Morgan' and 'CPR'. Since joining Chelsea, Joao Pedro has scored 20 goals and provided eight assists, directly contributing to 36.4% of the club’s 77 Premier League goals.
Whether Joao Pedro is Chelsea’s most important player remains open to debate. The statistics show that the club’s points return with him is consistent with Champions League qualification, while its return without him is not. Alonso’s team have yet to show they can perform at the same level when the Brazilian is unavailable.
