The UK has agreed to structured dialogue with Commonwealth leaders after Prime Minister Andy Burnham said he was open to calls for a formal apology for Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade. He has ruled out financial reparations, saying people in Britain today could not be held liable for historical wrongs.

Britain has previously expressed sorrow, but campaigners say those statements do not amount to a formal apology. In 2006, then-prime minister Tony Blair expressed “deep sorrow” for the slave trade. A year later, before the 200th anniversary of its abolition, he said: “I have said we are sorry and I say it again. We have to remember what happened in the past, to condemn it and say why it was entirely unacceptable.”

The Caribbean Community (Caricom) sets out a formal apology as the first step in its 10-point reparations plan. It says an apology should come from a monarch or head of government, acknowledge harms caused by the nation, its institutions and citizens, identify victims and perpetrators, apologise to victims and their descendants, and commit to reparatory justice.

Dorbrene O’Marde, chair of the Antigua and Barbuda Reparations Support Commission, says an apology “establishes acceptance of historical responsibility for the commission of the gravest crime against humanity and signals a commitment … to repair the damage caused.” He says: “Statements of sorrow or of regret are but emotional expressions void of acceptance of responsibility.”

Damon Corrie, faithkeeper of the Eagle Clan of the Lokono-Arawak Tribal Nation, says acknowledgment and contrition are important to healing for Indigenous Caribbean communities affected by British colonialism. “From an Indigenous spirituality and traditional cosmovision perspective, the first step to any sincere healing is the acknowledgment wrong has been done, and the genuine display or act of contrition, of what you would call an apology.”

Wendel Abel, a former professor of psychiatry at the University of the West Indies, describes acknowledging harm, apologising and making atonement as a “triple A strategy” for healing. He points to truth and reconciliation processes in South Africa and Rwanda, saying they allowed people to work through trauma.

Abel cites American researcher and clinical psychologist Joy DeGruy’s idea of post-traumatic slave syndrome, which he says describes intergenerational psychological impacts of slavery and racial trauma, including a “persistent lack of self-esteem and pervasive feelings of anger”. Without an apology, he says, people become “stuck” and unable to move on to healing.

King Charles has described enslavement as an “appalling atrocity” that left an “indelible stain on the history of our world”. In an address to Commonwealth heads of government meeting (Chogm) earlier this month, he called it a shameful chapter of history “that fills my heart with horror and my soul with the most profound personal sorrow”. Campaigners in the Caribbean reparations movement criticised the speech as recycled platitudes.

Sonjah Stanley Niaah, director of the University of the West Indies Centre for Reparation Research, asked: “What prevents his majesty the king from moving beyond repeated expressions of deep personal sorrow to offer a formal apology on behalf of his very own family following research into the family which proves that they profited heavily from racialised chattel enslavement?”

Britain has issued apologies for other historical wrongs. In 2010, David Cameron gave a formal state apology for the “unjustified and unjustifiable” killing of 14 civil rights marchers by British soldiers in Derry on 30 January 1972. After a public inquiry, he told the Commons: “What happened on Bloody Sunday was unjustified and unjustifiable. It was wrong.”

In 2012, after an independent report on documents relating to the Hillsborough disaster was released, Cameron said he was “profoundly sorry”. He said families had faced a double injustice: delays in learning the truth because of state failure, and the “denigration of their deceased” loved ones.

In 2013, then-foreign secretary William Hague apologised for torture committed by British officials during Kenya’s anti-colonial Mau Mau rebellion in the 1950s. Almost 1.5 million Kikuyu people were detained in camps, subjected to forced labour and systemic violence. Hague referred to “abhorrent violations of human dignity”, but said a £19.9m settlement did not set a legal precedent and denied legal liability for the colonial administration’s actions.

In 2018, then-prime minister Theresa May apologised after thousands of people legally resident in Britain, many born in the Caribbean, were wrongly classified as immigration offenders. “I take this issue very seriously. The home secretary apologised in the House of Commons yesterday for any anxiety caused. And I want to apologise to you today because we are genuinely sorry for any anxiety that has been caused,” she told Caribbean leaders.

Keir Starmer formally apologised in July 2026 for the British state’s role in historical forced adoptions. He said “the shame is ours” and that he was “deeply and profoundly sorry”. The apology followed years of campaigning by mothers and children and was accompanied by extra funding to help people access adoption records and reconnect with their biological families.