Finding the best sunscreen for your skin type already feels like a balancing act. Throw acne-prone skin in the mix, and suddenly shopping for sun protection has a whole new set of requirements. Will it clog pores? Will it leave you shiny? Luckily, you don’t have to settle for a thick, heavy glob of sunscreen to get adequate sun protection.

If every formula you’ve tried has left you with some sort of regret (or worse, an angry breakout), you’re in luck: These sunscreens won’t aggravate active blemishes or leave behind a greasy finish. After all, who wants to spend their afternoon doing a midday shine check?

But accounting for acne is only part of the equation—you can find options that have a tint for low-key coverage, soothing ingredients to dial down redness, and plenty of barrier support. Luckily, these gentle, acne-friendly sunscreens offer plenty of UV protection without feeling heavy or irritating existing breakouts.

Ahead, the reliable sunscreens our editors swear by and the tried-and-true formulas dermatologists recommend.