Spaghetti bolognese is popular around the world, but it is not served under that name in Bologna. In the Italian city, diners asking for it are more likely to be offered tagliatelle and a lesson in local food history.
Many Bolognese consider the dish a distorted version of their cuisine. In February 2019, then-mayor Virginio Merola asked residents on Twitter to send photos of spaghetti bolognese spotted abroad, beginning with a London restaurant’s chalkboard. He told journalists it was “embarrassing to be known around the world for something that doesn’t exist”.
A few months earlier, the Accademia Italiana della Cucina had registered a recipe for spaghetti in a tinned tuna sauce, described as “Bolognese style”, with Bologna’s chamber of commerce. The press called it the real spaghetti bolognese. The article says the dish appears to have originated around Rome in the early 1900s and has little or nothing to do with Bologna.
The city’s name was known internationally long before spaghetti bolognese became popular. Bologna had been associated with mortadella for centuries, and from the late 19th century the city’s charcutiers began putting the cured meat in tins for export.
The article traces Bolognese ragù in cookbooks to 1891, when Pellegrino Artusi published “Maccheroni alla bolognese” in Science in the Kitchen and the Art of Eating Well. The recipe used lean veal, pancetta, butter, onion, carrot and stock, but no tomato. It called for dried durum wheat maccheroni rather than tagliatelle.
Spaghetti appeared alongside ragù soon after. An 1898 advertisement for the Hôtel Ville et Bologne in Turin offered “Spaghetti di Napoli alla bolognese”. While fresh pasta and ragù became the pairing in Bologna, spaghetti bolognese gained popularity abroad, particularly in the United States, where egg pasta was harder to find.
In 1917, Julia Lovejoy Cuniberti translated Artusi’s recipe and suggested serving the sauce with “macaroni or spaghetti”. In 1952, at a fair at London’s Royal Festival Hall, the Queen Mother recognised spaghetti bolognese shortly before being welcomed at the British stand with a cup of tea.
The article argues that spaghetti bolognese has a place despite its rejection in Bologna. Visitors ordering it in the city, however, can expect to be corrected, kindly but firmly.
