Alan Milburn’s proposals to help more young people into work would save the government only £200m a year, as the cost of a new support system would absorb almost all the expected savings from benefit cuts.
The former health secretary published his long-awaited report on youth unemployment on Tuesday. It recommends reducing disability and sickness payments for under-25s and using the money to fund employment support. Figures in the report show the proposals would not produce significant overall savings.
The figures are likely to be cited by the Conservatives as evidence Labour is not serious about reducing welfare spending. But they also support Milburn’s and the prime minister, Andy Burnham’s, argument that the year-long review was not driven by a desire to make cuts. “The system I propose will spend less on compensating for economic inactivity, more on creating routes out of it; less on the consequences of failure and more on avoiding it,” Milburn said in the report.
At a meeting with Labour MPs on Monday night, Milburn said: “The Tories will say it’s too expensive, you can cut faster. But you can’t – or you’d drive young people into destitution with poor housing and ill health.”
The report sets out proposals to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training (Neet). It calls for nearly £2bn a year for a new youth opportunity service, offering support and advice to give every young person a guaranteed route into education, training or work.
The plan also proposes spending just over £2bn on vocational training and apprenticeships, and a further £1bn on direct payments and tax breaks for companies that hire young people.
The new system would be funded largely by reducing disability and sickness benefits for young people and replacing them with a single youth allowance, set below what some people can currently claim. People aged 18-24 would no longer be able to claim personal independence payments. A new allowance would be available only to those whose conditions are “well established, significant and ongoing”.
The benefit changes are expected to save £3.6bn by 2036-37, with another £2.4bn generated through higher tax receipts. Milburn said the £6bn in savings would be almost entirely absorbed by the new system’s £5.8bn cost.
Milburn began his review last year amid concern in government about the rising number of young people classed as Neet. The figure reached 1m earlier this year, equivalent to 13% of young people and a higher rate than in any European country except Romania.
Milburn said in the report: “Our country is at a fork in the road. Go on as we are and see the Neet crisis grow. Or change course and make the difficult changes that can shift the trajectory.” He described his proposals as a wholesale rethink of how the benefits and education systems work for young people, and said ministers should not select only the measures they support.
Milburn has received public backing from the governments of Burnham and his predecessor, Keir Starmer. At Monday’s meeting with Labour MPs, he was accompanied by work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden. McFadden and Burnham are due to address the parliamentary party about the plans again on Tuesday morning.
Ministers hope to avoid a repeat of last year’s welfare rebellion, when Labour MPs forced Starmer to abandon plans to cut benefits by about £5bn a year. Several architects of the rebellion now hold government roles, including the de facto deputy prime minister, Louise Haigh, and chief whip Anneliese Midgley.
