PC Gamer writer Mollie Taylor says spending more time in World of Warcraft: Forever and discovering its loop music setting has given her a new appreciation for the game’s soundtrack and ambient music, despite her earlier criticism of its long silences and emphasis on atmosphere over theatrics.

Taylor contrasts the subtler approach with Final Fantasy 14, whose music, she says, is often grand and thematic. She points to the Gold Saucer, Gridania’s outer Shroud zones and Ishgard, and describes composer Masayoshi Soken’s use of leitmotifs and orchestral spectacle.

A fan of JRPG soundtracks, Taylor also praises games with more pared-down music. She calls Minecraft’s OST “a masterclass in ambience” and says she has “a huge soft spot” for the Mirror’s Edge soundtrack, which builds in intensity when Faith is in danger.

Taylor asks readers whether they prefer atmospheric game soundtracks or music that is louder and more dramatic, and invites them to share their favourite and explain why.