Prosecutor Brett Hatfield SC has described Beau Lamarre-Condon’s account of the deaths of Jesse Baird and Luke Davies as “fanciful in the extreme”, arguing that forensic and ballistics evidence alone could support convictions. Hatfield began his closing statement on Thursday, in the ninth week of the double murder trial.
The former police officer is accused of fatally shooting Baird and his new partner, Davies, with his police service weapon at Baird’s Paddington home in Sydney on 19 February 2024. Lamarre-Condon has pleaded not guilty to two counts of murder and one charge of aggravated break and enter.
The defence has argued the men died during struggles with Lamarre-Condon, who acted in “self-defence”. Lamarre-Condon previously told the court he aimed to shoot Baird in the shoulder to make him drop a knife, then accidentally shot him a second time as they fell to the ground.
Hatfield told the court the injury from the first shot would cause someone to pass out. “Common sense renders it completely improbable that you could suffer such an injury yet immediately grab hold of a pistol with your left and forcefully pull a person brandishing it to the ground,” he said. “Such a scenario, you might think, is fanciful in the extreme.”
The prosecutor said forensic evidence about the bullet’s direction and Baird’s wounds indicated Lamarre-Condon shot Baird in the back as he fled towards the back door. The prosecution argued the height of the bullet marks meant Baird must have been ducking or stooping.
Hatfield said the bullet’s near-vertical trajectory through the floor indicated a controlled shot through Baird’s temple, which he called an “execution-style shot”. The timing between the two shots allowed only for a quick two to three steps, he told the court, “Not the bizarre wrestling and yanking the accused has described.”
Hatfield said Davies must have realised something was “seriously amiss” and tried to call triple zero. He said Davies was then killed by a bullet that passed through the door and into his head, and that gunshot stippling was present on the door but not the body.
Hatfield told the jury that claims Baird lunged at Lamarre-Condon with a knife and Davies picked up the gun and pointed it at him came only from the former officer. “Nothing independent of him supports any of what he said about those events,” Hatfield said.
The trial before Justice Natalie Adams continues.
