A new InfluenceMap analysis finds that the Business Council of Australia’s (BCA) climate and energy advocacy aligns more closely with fossil fuel companies Woodside, Santos and ConocoPhillips than with the positions of most members assessed. The report says the BCA has advocated for new gas supplies rather than a phase-down.

InfluenceMap assessed 58 companies, a representative sample of the BCA’s more than 120 members, using thousands of public statements, government submissions and regulatory filings. It found 69% of the companies assessed supported stronger climate policies than the BCA, rising to 78% on energy transition issues.

Those companies include Qantas, Woolworths, Coles, Atlassian, Fortescue and major banks CBA and NAB. Their support typically includes faster renewable energy rollout and more ambitious emissions reduction targets.

InfluenceMap’s Australia lead, Jack Herring, said major associations such as the BCA have influence in government policymaking. “These findings suggest the BCA’s climate policy engagement better reflects the narrow interests of members connected to the fossil fuel value chain than its wider membership,” he said.

Herring also said the BCA does not publicly disclose the membership of its internal climate and energy committees, raising questions about how its policy positions are formed. “We obviously do know who’s on the association board, but beyond that, there’s no transparency around those internal committees,” he said.

A BCA spokesperson said the association supported the “national goal of achieving net zero by 2050 and the setting of interim targets, while also delivering reliable and affordable energy and ensuring we don’t undermine our international competitiveness along the way”. The spokesperson said: “The BCA has long advocated for gas as an essential part of the net zero transition – ensuring grid stability – while we move to greater reliance on renewable energy.”

The BCA declined to comment on the makeup of its climate and energy committee.

The analysis comes as industry groups lobby over the “safeguard mechanism”, Australia’s main policy for curbing emissions from its largest industrial facilities, which is under federal review. The BCA and most big resources companies publicly support the Paris agreement and Australia’s net zero 2050 carbon emissions target, but interpret the commitments differently from what is widely regarded as climate best practice.

Several oil and gas producer members, including Woodside, say increased gas supply is needed to support the shift to renewables and enhance energy security. InfluenceMap said that position, adopted by the BCA, conflicts with the views of members aligned with the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, which found emissions from existing fossil fuel infrastructure were more than enough to push the world beyond its climate goals.

InfluenceMap also found the BCA frequently advocates a “technology-neutral” or “technology agnostic” energy transition. Persephone Fraser, ethical research and climate policy lead at Australian Ethical, said misaligned lobbying posed significant risks to companies, shareholders and the economy. “Companies must be scrutinising what is being advocated for in their name and actively correcting the record when it is inconsistent with their own positions, and interests,” she said. “Membership of an industry association cannot mean outsourcing responsibility for climate lobbying.”